A Note on Class, Dispositions and Radical Politics

James Avis

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This paper has set itself a number of tasks. The starting point is with
Smyth and Simmons’ discussion of the affective dispositions of the
working class. Rather than exploring the dispositions of members of the
working class, the paper examines the attribution of these, not only to the
working class but also to other groups. Research addressing the
capitalist division of labour in the early years of the twenty’s century has
illustrated the arbitrariness of this process. This leads into a discussion
of the attribution of dispositions and the salience not only of the
corporate gaze, but also the white gaze as well as those related to the
class, age, race and gender. Research that has addressed aesthetic
labour has often attributed ‘looking good’ and ‘sounding right’ to people
who are assumed to be middle class, the consequence is that an
understanding of class as a relation to capital is underplayed as is the
resulting politics. A homogenised view of the working class is debilitating
and leads to a restrictive understanding of class. Such as stance ignores
the re-composition of class relations and the potential for alliances that
include members of this putative middle class. An engagement with the
affective dispositions of the working class may serve to construct an
image of a homogeneous potentially radical class, yet at the same time it
serves to exclude constituencies that could play an important role in the struggle for a just society. Such as struggle would presage alliances in
the pursuit of a socially just society.
LanguageEnglish
Pages166-184
Number of pages19
JournalJournal for Critical Education Policy Studies
Volume16
Issue number3
Publication statusPublished - Dec 2018

Fingerprint

disposition
politics
working class
attribution
middle class
division of labor
gender
Group
Society

Cite this

@article{41ab27a1015e41ca9239080b810759a6,
title = "A Note on Class, Dispositions and Radical Politics",
abstract = "This paper has set itself a number of tasks. The starting point is withSmyth and Simmons’ discussion of the affective dispositions of theworking class. Rather than exploring the dispositions of members of theworking class, the paper examines the attribution of these, not only to theworking class but also to other groups. Research addressing thecapitalist division of labour in the early years of the twenty’s century hasillustrated the arbitrariness of this process. This leads into a discussionof the attribution of dispositions and the salience not only of thecorporate gaze, but also the white gaze as well as those related to theclass, age, race and gender. Research that has addressed aestheticlabour has often attributed ‘looking good’ and ‘sounding right’ to peoplewho are assumed to be middle class, the consequence is that anunderstanding of class as a relation to capital is underplayed as is theresulting politics. A homogenised view of the working class is debilitatingand leads to a restrictive understanding of class. Such as stance ignoresthe re-composition of class relations and the potential for alliances thatinclude members of this putative middle class. An engagement with theaffective dispositions of the working class may serve to construct animage of a homogeneous potentially radical class, yet at the same time itserves to exclude constituencies that could play an important role in the struggle for a just society. Such as struggle would presage alliances inthe pursuit of a socially just society.",
author = "James Avis",
year = "2018",
month = "12",
language = "English",
volume = "16",
pages = "166--184",
journal = "Journal for Critical Education Policy Studies",
issn = "2051-0969",
publisher = "Institute for Education Policy Studies",
number = "3",

}

A Note on Class, Dispositions and Radical Politics. / Avis, James.

In: Journal for Critical Education Policy Studies, Vol. 16, No. 3, 12.2018, p. 166-184.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - A Note on Class, Dispositions and Radical Politics

AU - Avis, James

PY - 2018/12

Y1 - 2018/12

N2 - This paper has set itself a number of tasks. The starting point is withSmyth and Simmons’ discussion of the affective dispositions of theworking class. Rather than exploring the dispositions of members of theworking class, the paper examines the attribution of these, not only to theworking class but also to other groups. Research addressing thecapitalist division of labour in the early years of the twenty’s century hasillustrated the arbitrariness of this process. This leads into a discussionof the attribution of dispositions and the salience not only of thecorporate gaze, but also the white gaze as well as those related to theclass, age, race and gender. Research that has addressed aestheticlabour has often attributed ‘looking good’ and ‘sounding right’ to peoplewho are assumed to be middle class, the consequence is that anunderstanding of class as a relation to capital is underplayed as is theresulting politics. A homogenised view of the working class is debilitatingand leads to a restrictive understanding of class. Such as stance ignoresthe re-composition of class relations and the potential for alliances thatinclude members of this putative middle class. An engagement with theaffective dispositions of the working class may serve to construct animage of a homogeneous potentially radical class, yet at the same time itserves to exclude constituencies that could play an important role in the struggle for a just society. Such as struggle would presage alliances inthe pursuit of a socially just society.

AB - This paper has set itself a number of tasks. The starting point is withSmyth and Simmons’ discussion of the affective dispositions of theworking class. Rather than exploring the dispositions of members of theworking class, the paper examines the attribution of these, not only to theworking class but also to other groups. Research addressing thecapitalist division of labour in the early years of the twenty’s century hasillustrated the arbitrariness of this process. This leads into a discussionof the attribution of dispositions and the salience not only of thecorporate gaze, but also the white gaze as well as those related to theclass, age, race and gender. Research that has addressed aestheticlabour has often attributed ‘looking good’ and ‘sounding right’ to peoplewho are assumed to be middle class, the consequence is that anunderstanding of class as a relation to capital is underplayed as is theresulting politics. A homogenised view of the working class is debilitatingand leads to a restrictive understanding of class. Such as stance ignoresthe re-composition of class relations and the potential for alliances thatinclude members of this putative middle class. An engagement with theaffective dispositions of the working class may serve to construct animage of a homogeneous potentially radical class, yet at the same time itserves to exclude constituencies that could play an important role in the struggle for a just society. Such as struggle would presage alliances inthe pursuit of a socially just society.

M3 - Article

VL - 16

SP - 166

EP - 184

JO - Journal for Critical Education Policy Studies

T2 - Journal for Critical Education Policy Studies

JF - Journal for Critical Education Policy Studies

SN - 2051-0969

IS - 3

ER -