A Socio-Cultural Exploration of the Mechanisms Underpinning Performance Dips Following Transition from Primary to Secondary School

Elizabeth Tobbell, Victoria O'Donnell

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

A range of transition research suggests that students undergo a dip in performance subsequent to an educational transition. In this paper, through consideration of ethnographic data and recent situated theoretical conceptualisations of learning and teaching, we explore the mechanism of this phenomenon. We argue here for the use of situated learning models where all knowledge is understood as being contextualised in the activities and practices of both the learning situation and the wider societal frameworks which construct that situation. We explore children in transition and the concomitant learning and teaching practices in a UK school. We demonstrate that knowledge and performance is mediated by the practices that the new students must acquire in order to participate in their new community. The data follow a group of year 7 children who are new to the school and their teacher over a three week period engaged in work on averages. In their efforts to adopt the practices dictated by the teacher, the data demonstrate that conceptual and procedural understanding shifts from one of confidence to one of hesitancy and questioning. Understanding of children in transition, school performance and the attendant teaching practices are discussed in light of the data.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)159-176
Number of pages18
JournalJournal of Education and Human Development
Volume3
Issue number1
Publication statusPublished - Mar 2014

Fingerprint

secondary school
teaching practice
performance
school transition
learning
learning situation
teacher
school
student
confidence
Teaching
community
Group

Cite this

@article{c87677d4ba1a4ad4b43407154ac23ca9,
title = "A Socio-Cultural Exploration of the Mechanisms Underpinning Performance Dips Following Transition from Primary to Secondary School",
abstract = "A range of transition research suggests that students undergo a dip in performance subsequent to an educational transition. In this paper, through consideration of ethnographic data and recent situated theoretical conceptualisations of learning and teaching, we explore the mechanism of this phenomenon. We argue here for the use of situated learning models where all knowledge is understood as being contextualised in the activities and practices of both the learning situation and the wider societal frameworks which construct that situation. We explore children in transition and the concomitant learning and teaching practices in a UK school. We demonstrate that knowledge and performance is mediated by the practices that the new students must acquire in order to participate in their new community. The data follow a group of year 7 children who are new to the school and their teacher over a three week period engaged in work on averages. In their efforts to adopt the practices dictated by the teacher, the data demonstrate that conceptual and procedural understanding shifts from one of confidence to one of hesitancy and questioning. Understanding of children in transition, school performance and the attendant teaching practices are discussed in light of the data.",
keywords = "transition, socio-cultural theory, classroom practices, legitimate peripheral participation",
author = "Elizabeth Tobbell and Victoria O'Donnell",
year = "2014",
month = "3",
language = "English",
volume = "3",
pages = "159--176",
journal = "Journal of Education and Human Development",
issn = "2334-296X",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A Socio-Cultural Exploration of the Mechanisms Underpinning Performance Dips Following Transition from Primary to Secondary School

AU - Tobbell, Elizabeth

AU - O'Donnell, Victoria

PY - 2014/3

Y1 - 2014/3

N2 - A range of transition research suggests that students undergo a dip in performance subsequent to an educational transition. In this paper, through consideration of ethnographic data and recent situated theoretical conceptualisations of learning and teaching, we explore the mechanism of this phenomenon. We argue here for the use of situated learning models where all knowledge is understood as being contextualised in the activities and practices of both the learning situation and the wider societal frameworks which construct that situation. We explore children in transition and the concomitant learning and teaching practices in a UK school. We demonstrate that knowledge and performance is mediated by the practices that the new students must acquire in order to participate in their new community. The data follow a group of year 7 children who are new to the school and their teacher over a three week period engaged in work on averages. In their efforts to adopt the practices dictated by the teacher, the data demonstrate that conceptual and procedural understanding shifts from one of confidence to one of hesitancy and questioning. Understanding of children in transition, school performance and the attendant teaching practices are discussed in light of the data.

AB - A range of transition research suggests that students undergo a dip in performance subsequent to an educational transition. In this paper, through consideration of ethnographic data and recent situated theoretical conceptualisations of learning and teaching, we explore the mechanism of this phenomenon. We argue here for the use of situated learning models where all knowledge is understood as being contextualised in the activities and practices of both the learning situation and the wider societal frameworks which construct that situation. We explore children in transition and the concomitant learning and teaching practices in a UK school. We demonstrate that knowledge and performance is mediated by the practices that the new students must acquire in order to participate in their new community. The data follow a group of year 7 children who are new to the school and their teacher over a three week period engaged in work on averages. In their efforts to adopt the practices dictated by the teacher, the data demonstrate that conceptual and procedural understanding shifts from one of confidence to one of hesitancy and questioning. Understanding of children in transition, school performance and the attendant teaching practices are discussed in light of the data.

KW - transition

KW - socio-cultural theory

KW - classroom practices

KW - legitimate peripheral participation

M3 - Article

VL - 3

SP - 159

EP - 176

JO - Journal of Education and Human Development

JF - Journal of Education and Human Development

SN - 2334-296X

IS - 1

ER -