Acceptability and feasibility pilot randomised controlled trial of medical skin camouflage for recovery of women prisoners with self-harm scarring (COVER): the study protocol

Heather Mitchell, Kathryn Abel, Brendon Dunlop, Tammi Walker, Sandeep Ranote, Louise Robinson, Fiona Edgar, Tracy Millington, Rachel Meacock, Jenny Shaw, Kerry Gutridge

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract


Introduction: Self-harm in prison is a major public health concern. Less than 5% of UK prisoners are women, but they carry out more than a fifth of prison self-harm. Scars resulting from self-harm can be traumatising and stigmatising, yet there has been little focus on recovery of women prisoners with self-harm scarring. Medical skin camouflage (MSC) clinics treat individuals with disfiguring skin conditions, with evidence of improved well-being, self-esteem and social interactions. Only one community study has piloted the use of MSC for self-harm scarring.

Methods and analysis: We describe an acceptability and feasibility pilot randomised controlled trial; the first to examine MSC for women prisoners who self-harm. We aim to randomise 20–25 women prisoners to a 6-week MSC intervention and 20–25 to a waitlist control (to receive the MSC after the study period). We aim to train at least 6–10 long-term prisoners with personal experience of self-harm to deliver the intervention. Before and after intervention, we will pilot collection of women-centred outcomes, including quality of life, well-being and self-esteem. We will pilot collection of self-harm incidents during the intervention, resources used to manage/treat self-harm and follow-up of women at 12 weeks from baseline. Data on recruitment, retention and dropout will be recorded. We aim for the acceptability of the intervention to prison staff and women prisoners to be explored in qualitative interviews and focus groups.

Ethics and dissemination: Ethical approval for COVER has been granted by the North East–York Research Ethics Committee (REC) for phases 1 and 2 (reference: 16/NE/0030) and West of Scotland REC 3 for phases 3 and 4 (reference: 16/WS/0155). Informed consent will be the primary consideration; it will be made clear that participation will have no effect on life in prison or eligibility for parole. Due to the nature of the study, disclosures of serious self-harm may need to be reported to prison officials. We aim for findings to be disseminated via events at the study prison, presentations at national/international conferences, journal publications, prison governor meetings and university/National Health Service trust communications.

Trial registration number: NCT02638974; Pre-results.
LanguageEnglish
Article numbere021891
Pagese021891
Number of pages11
JournalBMJ Open
Volume9
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 19 Jan 2019

Fingerprint

Prisoners
Prisons
Cicatrix
Randomized Controlled Trials
Skin
Research Ethics Committees
Self Concept
Student Health Services
Disclosure
National Health Programs
Scotland
Interpersonal Relations
Focus Groups
Informed Consent
Ethics
Publications
Public Health
Communication
Quality of Life
Interviews

Cite this

Mitchell, Heather ; Abel, Kathryn ; Dunlop, Brendon ; Walker, Tammi ; Ranote, Sandeep ; Robinson, Louise ; Edgar, Fiona ; Millington, Tracy ; Meacock, Rachel ; Shaw, Jenny ; Gutridge, Kerry. / Acceptability and feasibility pilot randomised controlled trial of medical skin camouflage for recovery of women prisoners with self-harm scarring (COVER) : the study protocol. In: BMJ Open. 2019 ; Vol. 9, No. 1. pp. e021891.
@article{6837dba023554f45a34c6b6becc4babe,
title = "Acceptability and feasibility pilot randomised controlled trial of medical skin camouflage for recovery of women prisoners with self-harm scarring (COVER): the study protocol",
abstract = "Introduction: Self-harm in prison is a major public health concern. Less than 5{\%} of UK prisoners are women, but they carry out more than a fifth of prison self-harm. Scars resulting from self-harm can be traumatising and stigmatising, yet there has been little focus on recovery of women prisoners with self-harm scarring. Medical skin camouflage (MSC) clinics treat individuals with disfiguring skin conditions, with evidence of improved well-being, self-esteem and social interactions. Only one community study has piloted the use of MSC for self-harm scarring.Methods and analysis: We describe an acceptability and feasibility pilot randomised controlled trial; the first to examine MSC for women prisoners who self-harm. We aim to randomise 20–25 women prisoners to a 6-week MSC intervention and 20–25 to a waitlist control (to receive the MSC after the study period). We aim to train at least 6–10 long-term prisoners with personal experience of self-harm to deliver the intervention. Before and after intervention, we will pilot collection of women-centred outcomes, including quality of life, well-being and self-esteem. We will pilot collection of self-harm incidents during the intervention, resources used to manage/treat self-harm and follow-up of women at 12 weeks from baseline. Data on recruitment, retention and dropout will be recorded. We aim for the acceptability of the intervention to prison staff and women prisoners to be explored in qualitative interviews and focus groups.Ethics and dissemination: Ethical approval for COVER has been granted by the North East–York Research Ethics Committee (REC) for phases 1 and 2 (reference: 16/NE/0030) and West of Scotland REC 3 for phases 3 and 4 (reference: 16/WS/0155). Informed consent will be the primary consideration; it will be made clear that participation will have no effect on life in prison or eligibility for parole. Due to the nature of the study, disclosures of serious self-harm may need to be reported to prison officials. We aim for findings to be disseminated via events at the study prison, presentations at national/international conferences, journal publications, prison governor meetings and university/National Health Service trust communications.Trial registration number: NCT02638974; Pre-results.",
keywords = "feasibility trial, medical skin camouflage, recovery, scarring, self-harm, women prisoners",
author = "Heather Mitchell and Kathryn Abel and Brendon Dunlop and Tammi Walker and Sandeep Ranote and Louise Robinson and Fiona Edgar and Tracy Millington and Rachel Meacock and Jenny Shaw and Kerry Gutridge",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "19",
doi = "10.1136/bmjopen-2018-021891",
language = "English",
volume = "9",
pages = "e021891",
journal = "BMJ Open",
issn = "2044-6055",
publisher = "British Medical Journal Publishing Group",
number = "1",

}

Mitchell, H, Abel, K, Dunlop, B, Walker, T, Ranote, S, Robinson, L, Edgar, F, Millington, T, Meacock, R, Shaw, J & Gutridge, K 2019, 'Acceptability and feasibility pilot randomised controlled trial of medical skin camouflage for recovery of women prisoners with self-harm scarring (COVER): the study protocol', BMJ Open, vol. 9, no. 1, e021891, pp. e021891. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2018-021891

Acceptability and feasibility pilot randomised controlled trial of medical skin camouflage for recovery of women prisoners with self-harm scarring (COVER) : the study protocol. / Mitchell, Heather; Abel, Kathryn; Dunlop, Brendon ; Walker, Tammi; Ranote, Sandeep; Robinson, Louise; Edgar, Fiona; Millington, Tracy ; Meacock, Rachel; Shaw, Jenny; Gutridge, Kerry.

In: BMJ Open, Vol. 9, No. 1, e021891, 19.01.2019, p. e021891.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Acceptability and feasibility pilot randomised controlled trial of medical skin camouflage for recovery of women prisoners with self-harm scarring (COVER)

T2 - BMJ Open

AU - Mitchell, Heather

AU - Abel, Kathryn

AU - Dunlop, Brendon

AU - Walker, Tammi

AU - Ranote, Sandeep

AU - Robinson, Louise

AU - Edgar, Fiona

AU - Millington, Tracy

AU - Meacock, Rachel

AU - Shaw, Jenny

AU - Gutridge, Kerry

PY - 2019/1/19

Y1 - 2019/1/19

N2 - Introduction: Self-harm in prison is a major public health concern. Less than 5% of UK prisoners are women, but they carry out more than a fifth of prison self-harm. Scars resulting from self-harm can be traumatising and stigmatising, yet there has been little focus on recovery of women prisoners with self-harm scarring. Medical skin camouflage (MSC) clinics treat individuals with disfiguring skin conditions, with evidence of improved well-being, self-esteem and social interactions. Only one community study has piloted the use of MSC for self-harm scarring.Methods and analysis: We describe an acceptability and feasibility pilot randomised controlled trial; the first to examine MSC for women prisoners who self-harm. We aim to randomise 20–25 women prisoners to a 6-week MSC intervention and 20–25 to a waitlist control (to receive the MSC after the study period). We aim to train at least 6–10 long-term prisoners with personal experience of self-harm to deliver the intervention. Before and after intervention, we will pilot collection of women-centred outcomes, including quality of life, well-being and self-esteem. We will pilot collection of self-harm incidents during the intervention, resources used to manage/treat self-harm and follow-up of women at 12 weeks from baseline. Data on recruitment, retention and dropout will be recorded. We aim for the acceptability of the intervention to prison staff and women prisoners to be explored in qualitative interviews and focus groups.Ethics and dissemination: Ethical approval for COVER has been granted by the North East–York Research Ethics Committee (REC) for phases 1 and 2 (reference: 16/NE/0030) and West of Scotland REC 3 for phases 3 and 4 (reference: 16/WS/0155). Informed consent will be the primary consideration; it will be made clear that participation will have no effect on life in prison or eligibility for parole. Due to the nature of the study, disclosures of serious self-harm may need to be reported to prison officials. We aim for findings to be disseminated via events at the study prison, presentations at national/international conferences, journal publications, prison governor meetings and university/National Health Service trust communications.Trial registration number: NCT02638974; Pre-results.

AB - Introduction: Self-harm in prison is a major public health concern. Less than 5% of UK prisoners are women, but they carry out more than a fifth of prison self-harm. Scars resulting from self-harm can be traumatising and stigmatising, yet there has been little focus on recovery of women prisoners with self-harm scarring. Medical skin camouflage (MSC) clinics treat individuals with disfiguring skin conditions, with evidence of improved well-being, self-esteem and social interactions. Only one community study has piloted the use of MSC for self-harm scarring.Methods and analysis: We describe an acceptability and feasibility pilot randomised controlled trial; the first to examine MSC for women prisoners who self-harm. We aim to randomise 20–25 women prisoners to a 6-week MSC intervention and 20–25 to a waitlist control (to receive the MSC after the study period). We aim to train at least 6–10 long-term prisoners with personal experience of self-harm to deliver the intervention. Before and after intervention, we will pilot collection of women-centred outcomes, including quality of life, well-being and self-esteem. We will pilot collection of self-harm incidents during the intervention, resources used to manage/treat self-harm and follow-up of women at 12 weeks from baseline. Data on recruitment, retention and dropout will be recorded. We aim for the acceptability of the intervention to prison staff and women prisoners to be explored in qualitative interviews and focus groups.Ethics and dissemination: Ethical approval for COVER has been granted by the North East–York Research Ethics Committee (REC) for phases 1 and 2 (reference: 16/NE/0030) and West of Scotland REC 3 for phases 3 and 4 (reference: 16/WS/0155). Informed consent will be the primary consideration; it will be made clear that participation will have no effect on life in prison or eligibility for parole. Due to the nature of the study, disclosures of serious self-harm may need to be reported to prison officials. We aim for findings to be disseminated via events at the study prison, presentations at national/international conferences, journal publications, prison governor meetings and university/National Health Service trust communications.Trial registration number: NCT02638974; Pre-results.

KW - feasibility trial

KW - medical skin camouflage

KW - recovery

KW - scarring

KW - self-harm

KW - women prisoners

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85060085451&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1136/bmjopen-2018-021891

DO - 10.1136/bmjopen-2018-021891

M3 - Article

VL - 9

SP - e021891

JO - BMJ Open

JF - BMJ Open

SN - 2044-6055

IS - 1

M1 - e021891

ER -