An Interlaboratory Comparison of X-Ray Computed Tomography Measurement for Texture and Dimensional Characterisation of Additively Manufactured Parts

Andrew Townsend, Radu Racasan, Richard Leach, Nicola Senin, Adam Thompson, Andrew Ramsey, David Bate, Peter Woolliams, Stephen Brown, Liam Blunt

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

8 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This paper presents the results of the CT-STARR (CT-Surface Texture for Additive Round Robin) Stage 1 interlaboratory comparison. The study compared the results obtained for the extraction of areal surface texture data per ISO 25178-2 from five X-ray computed tomography (CT) volume measurements from each of four laboratories. Two Ti6Al4V ELI (extra-low interstitial) components were included in each of the CT acquisitions. The first component was an additively manufactured (AM) cube manufactured using an Arcam Q10 electron beam melting (EBM) machine. Surface texture data was extracted from CT scans of this part. The values of selected parameters per ISO 25178-2 are reported, including Sa, the arithmetic mean height, for which the values from the Nikon MCT 225 metrology CT measurements were all within 0.5% of the mean reference focus variation measurement. CT resolution requirements are discussed. The second component was a machined dimensional test artefact designed to facilitate independent analysis of CT global voxel scaling errors and surface determination errors. The results of mathematical global scaling and surface determination correction of the dimensional artefact data is reported. The dimensional test artefact errors for the XT H 225 commercial CT for length, outside diameter and inside diameter reduced from -0.27%, -0.83% and -0.54% respectively to less than 0.02% after performing mathematical correction. This work will assist the development of surface texture correction protocols, help define surface-from-CT measurement envelope limits and provide valuable information for an expanded Stage 2 interlaboratory comparison, which will include a more diverse range of CT systems and technologies, further expanding the surface-from-CT knowledge base.

LanguageEnglish
Pages422-432
Number of pages11
JournalAdditive Manufacturing
Volume23
Early online date16 Aug 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Oct 2018

Fingerprint

Tomography
Textures
X rays
Electron beam melting
Volume measurement
Optical resolving power

Cite this

Townsend, Andrew ; Racasan, Radu ; Leach, Richard ; Senin, Nicola ; Thompson, Adam ; Ramsey, Andrew ; Bate, David ; Woolliams, Peter ; Brown, Stephen ; Blunt, Liam. / An Interlaboratory Comparison of X-Ray Computed Tomography Measurement for Texture and Dimensional Characterisation of Additively Manufactured Parts. In: Additive Manufacturing. 2018 ; Vol. 23. pp. 422-432.
@article{d142b8c6bc3e436fa8cf3fccdad3527c,
title = "An Interlaboratory Comparison of X-Ray Computed Tomography Measurement for Texture and Dimensional Characterisation of Additively Manufactured Parts",
abstract = "This paper presents the results of the CT-STARR (CT-Surface Texture for Additive Round Robin) Stage 1 interlaboratory comparison. The study compared the results obtained for the extraction of areal surface texture data per ISO 25178-2 from five X-ray computed tomography (CT) volume measurements from each of four laboratories. Two Ti6Al4V ELI (extra-low interstitial) components were included in each of the CT acquisitions. The first component was an additively manufactured (AM) cube manufactured using an Arcam Q10 electron beam melting (EBM) machine. Surface texture data was extracted from CT scans of this part. The values of selected parameters per ISO 25178-2 are reported, including Sa, the arithmetic mean height, for which the values from the Nikon MCT 225 metrology CT measurements were all within 0.5{\%} of the mean reference focus variation measurement. CT resolution requirements are discussed. The second component was a machined dimensional test artefact designed to facilitate independent analysis of CT global voxel scaling errors and surface determination errors. The results of mathematical global scaling and surface determination correction of the dimensional artefact data is reported. The dimensional test artefact errors for the XT H 225 commercial CT for length, outside diameter and inside diameter reduced from -0.27{\%}, -0.83{\%} and -0.54{\%} respectively to less than 0.02{\%} after performing mathematical correction. This work will assist the development of surface texture correction protocols, help define surface-from-CT measurement envelope limits and provide valuable information for an expanded Stage 2 interlaboratory comparison, which will include a more diverse range of CT systems and technologies, further expanding the surface-from-CT knowledge base.",
keywords = "Additive manufacturing, ISO 25178, Metrology, Surface texture, X-ray computed tomography",
author = "Andrew Townsend and Radu Racasan and Richard Leach and Nicola Senin and Adam Thompson and Andrew Ramsey and David Bate and Peter Woolliams and Stephen Brown and Liam Blunt",
year = "2018",
month = "10",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.addma.2018.08.013",
language = "English",
volume = "23",
pages = "422--432",
journal = "Additive Manufacturing",
issn = "2214-8604",
publisher = "Elsevier BV",

}

An Interlaboratory Comparison of X-Ray Computed Tomography Measurement for Texture and Dimensional Characterisation of Additively Manufactured Parts. / Townsend, Andrew; Racasan, Radu; Leach, Richard; Senin, Nicola; Thompson, Adam; Ramsey, Andrew; Bate, David; Woolliams, Peter; Brown, Stephen; Blunt, Liam.

In: Additive Manufacturing, Vol. 23, 01.10.2018, p. 422-432.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - An Interlaboratory Comparison of X-Ray Computed Tomography Measurement for Texture and Dimensional Characterisation of Additively Manufactured Parts

AU - Townsend, Andrew

AU - Racasan, Radu

AU - Leach, Richard

AU - Senin, Nicola

AU - Thompson, Adam

AU - Ramsey, Andrew

AU - Bate, David

AU - Woolliams, Peter

AU - Brown, Stephen

AU - Blunt, Liam

PY - 2018/10/1

Y1 - 2018/10/1

N2 - This paper presents the results of the CT-STARR (CT-Surface Texture for Additive Round Robin) Stage 1 interlaboratory comparison. The study compared the results obtained for the extraction of areal surface texture data per ISO 25178-2 from five X-ray computed tomography (CT) volume measurements from each of four laboratories. Two Ti6Al4V ELI (extra-low interstitial) components were included in each of the CT acquisitions. The first component was an additively manufactured (AM) cube manufactured using an Arcam Q10 electron beam melting (EBM) machine. Surface texture data was extracted from CT scans of this part. The values of selected parameters per ISO 25178-2 are reported, including Sa, the arithmetic mean height, for which the values from the Nikon MCT 225 metrology CT measurements were all within 0.5% of the mean reference focus variation measurement. CT resolution requirements are discussed. The second component was a machined dimensional test artefact designed to facilitate independent analysis of CT global voxel scaling errors and surface determination errors. The results of mathematical global scaling and surface determination correction of the dimensional artefact data is reported. The dimensional test artefact errors for the XT H 225 commercial CT for length, outside diameter and inside diameter reduced from -0.27%, -0.83% and -0.54% respectively to less than 0.02% after performing mathematical correction. This work will assist the development of surface texture correction protocols, help define surface-from-CT measurement envelope limits and provide valuable information for an expanded Stage 2 interlaboratory comparison, which will include a more diverse range of CT systems and technologies, further expanding the surface-from-CT knowledge base.

AB - This paper presents the results of the CT-STARR (CT-Surface Texture for Additive Round Robin) Stage 1 interlaboratory comparison. The study compared the results obtained for the extraction of areal surface texture data per ISO 25178-2 from five X-ray computed tomography (CT) volume measurements from each of four laboratories. Two Ti6Al4V ELI (extra-low interstitial) components were included in each of the CT acquisitions. The first component was an additively manufactured (AM) cube manufactured using an Arcam Q10 electron beam melting (EBM) machine. Surface texture data was extracted from CT scans of this part. The values of selected parameters per ISO 25178-2 are reported, including Sa, the arithmetic mean height, for which the values from the Nikon MCT 225 metrology CT measurements were all within 0.5% of the mean reference focus variation measurement. CT resolution requirements are discussed. The second component was a machined dimensional test artefact designed to facilitate independent analysis of CT global voxel scaling errors and surface determination errors. The results of mathematical global scaling and surface determination correction of the dimensional artefact data is reported. The dimensional test artefact errors for the XT H 225 commercial CT for length, outside diameter and inside diameter reduced from -0.27%, -0.83% and -0.54% respectively to less than 0.02% after performing mathematical correction. This work will assist the development of surface texture correction protocols, help define surface-from-CT measurement envelope limits and provide valuable information for an expanded Stage 2 interlaboratory comparison, which will include a more diverse range of CT systems and technologies, further expanding the surface-from-CT knowledge base.

KW - Additive manufacturing

KW - ISO 25178

KW - Metrology

KW - Surface texture

KW - X-ray computed tomography

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85052665565&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.addma.2018.08.013

DO - 10.1016/j.addma.2018.08.013

M3 - Article

VL - 23

SP - 422

EP - 432

JO - Additive Manufacturing

T2 - Additive Manufacturing

JF - Additive Manufacturing

SN - 2214-8604

ER -