Can knowledge be retained in informal organisational networks?

Moheeb Abualqumboz, Iain Reid, Marina Papalexi, David Bamford

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Abstract

Taking a constructivist view of knowledge where it is viewed as a 'process of knowing', the literature on knowledge sharing assumes that it can be retained through embedding within institutional routines, structures, and systems. However, this concept is challenged in the context of informal organisational networks where membership is voluntary, temporary and organisationally unsanctioned. Such challenges have predominately focused around: 1) behavioural aspects including organisational and individual defence mechanisms to protect knowledge and opportunistic behaviours such as free-riding; or 2) social aspects including lack of mutual trust and asymmetric power relations. We therefore consider the mechanisms and theoretical underpinning of socially constructed knowledge across a number of informal networks. This paper investigates the challenges to knowledge retention in knowledge-sharing networks, reporting on data collected from a case study of four informal organisational networks in the UK (two photography networks; women entrepreneurship network; and a construction network). There is a significant amount of literature addressing such challenges on an organisational level, however, less research exists on the network level. In particular, the challenge of knowledge retention within networks. This research adopts Social Exchange Theory in order to develop the theoretical underpinning and data interpretation. The paper also presents an explanatory model to inform theorists and practitioners on how to improve knowledge retention in networks. A qualitative approach was used through an ethnographic lens consisting of 18 months participant observation study that produced 28 semi-structured interviews. The study also utilised data from network archive network spanning two years. This paper argues that knowledge shared in the networks largely remained inside them and that less knowledge was shared with networked organisations making the network knowledge "ontologically" separate from knowledge created in organisations. The data also revealed that 'boundary spanners' found it difficult to share knowledge between their formally contracted organisation and the informal network, due to issues related to trust and unbalanced reciprocal exchanges. Our investigation of knowledge sharing in those networks demonstrates the difficulty in retaining it on a network level due to blurring organisational boundaries and the temporary nature of such networks.

Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationProceedings of the 18th European Conference on Knowledge Management, ECKM 2017
PublisherAcademic Conferences Limited
Pages1-7
Number of pages7
Volume1
ISBN (Electronic)9781911218487
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jan 2017
Event18th European Conference on Knowledge Management - International University of Catalonia , Barcelona, Spain
Duration: 7 Sep 20178 Sep 2017
Conference number: 18
https://www.academic-conferences.org/conferences/eckm/future-past-conferences/ (Link to Conference Details)

Conference

Conference18th European Conference on Knowledge Management
Abbreviated titleECKM 2017
CountrySpain
CityBarcelona
Period7/09/178/09/17
Internet address

Fingerprint

Organizational networks
Knowledge sharing
Informal networks
Photography
Knowledge networks
Boundary spanners
Opportunistic behavior
Power relations
Women's entrepreneurship
Social exchange theory
Organizational boundaries
Participant observation
Qualitative approaches
Organizational level
Free-riding
Shared knowledge
Structured interview
Organizational aspects

Cite this

Abualqumboz, M., Reid, I., Papalexi, M., & Bamford, D. (2017). Can knowledge be retained in informal organisational networks? In Proceedings of the 18th European Conference on Knowledge Management, ECKM 2017 (Vol. 1, pp. 1-7). Academic Conferences Limited.
Abualqumboz, Moheeb ; Reid, Iain ; Papalexi, Marina ; Bamford, David. / Can knowledge be retained in informal organisational networks?. Proceedings of the 18th European Conference on Knowledge Management, ECKM 2017. Vol. 1 Academic Conferences Limited, 2017. pp. 1-7
@inproceedings{e5ec507287734129afc1062dc86d16ba,
title = "Can knowledge be retained in informal organisational networks?",
abstract = "Taking a constructivist view of knowledge where it is viewed as a 'process of knowing', the literature on knowledge sharing assumes that it can be retained through embedding within institutional routines, structures, and systems. However, this concept is challenged in the context of informal organisational networks where membership is voluntary, temporary and organisationally unsanctioned. Such challenges have predominately focused around: 1) behavioural aspects including organisational and individual defence mechanisms to protect knowledge and opportunistic behaviours such as free-riding; or 2) social aspects including lack of mutual trust and asymmetric power relations. We therefore consider the mechanisms and theoretical underpinning of socially constructed knowledge across a number of informal networks. This paper investigates the challenges to knowledge retention in knowledge-sharing networks, reporting on data collected from a case study of four informal organisational networks in the UK (two photography networks; women entrepreneurship network; and a construction network). There is a significant amount of literature addressing such challenges on an organisational level, however, less research exists on the network level. In particular, the challenge of knowledge retention within networks. This research adopts Social Exchange Theory in order to develop the theoretical underpinning and data interpretation. The paper also presents an explanatory model to inform theorists and practitioners on how to improve knowledge retention in networks. A qualitative approach was used through an ethnographic lens consisting of 18 months participant observation study that produced 28 semi-structured interviews. The study also utilised data from network archive network spanning two years. This paper argues that knowledge shared in the networks largely remained inside them and that less knowledge was shared with networked organisations making the network knowledge {"}ontologically{"} separate from knowledge created in organisations. The data also revealed that 'boundary spanners' found it difficult to share knowledge between their formally contracted organisation and the informal network, due to issues related to trust and unbalanced reciprocal exchanges. Our investigation of knowledge sharing in those networks demonstrates the difficulty in retaining it on a network level due to blurring organisational boundaries and the temporary nature of such networks.",
keywords = "Boundary spanners, Inter-organisational learning, Knowledge retention, Knowledge sharing, Networks",
author = "Moheeb Abualqumboz and Iain Reid and Marina Papalexi and David Bamford",
year = "2017",
month = "1",
day = "1",
language = "English",
volume = "1",
pages = "1--7",
booktitle = "Proceedings of the 18th European Conference on Knowledge Management, ECKM 2017",
publisher = "Academic Conferences Limited",

}

Abualqumboz, M, Reid, I, Papalexi, M & Bamford, D 2017, Can knowledge be retained in informal organisational networks? in Proceedings of the 18th European Conference on Knowledge Management, ECKM 2017. vol. 1, Academic Conferences Limited, pp. 1-7, 18th European Conference on Knowledge Management, Barcelona, Spain, 7/09/17.

Can knowledge be retained in informal organisational networks? / Abualqumboz, Moheeb; Reid, Iain; Papalexi, Marina; Bamford, David.

Proceedings of the 18th European Conference on Knowledge Management, ECKM 2017. Vol. 1 Academic Conferences Limited, 2017. p. 1-7.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

TY - GEN

T1 - Can knowledge be retained in informal organisational networks?

AU - Abualqumboz, Moheeb

AU - Reid, Iain

AU - Papalexi, Marina

AU - Bamford, David

PY - 2017/1/1

Y1 - 2017/1/1

N2 - Taking a constructivist view of knowledge where it is viewed as a 'process of knowing', the literature on knowledge sharing assumes that it can be retained through embedding within institutional routines, structures, and systems. However, this concept is challenged in the context of informal organisational networks where membership is voluntary, temporary and organisationally unsanctioned. Such challenges have predominately focused around: 1) behavioural aspects including organisational and individual defence mechanisms to protect knowledge and opportunistic behaviours such as free-riding; or 2) social aspects including lack of mutual trust and asymmetric power relations. We therefore consider the mechanisms and theoretical underpinning of socially constructed knowledge across a number of informal networks. This paper investigates the challenges to knowledge retention in knowledge-sharing networks, reporting on data collected from a case study of four informal organisational networks in the UK (two photography networks; women entrepreneurship network; and a construction network). There is a significant amount of literature addressing such challenges on an organisational level, however, less research exists on the network level. In particular, the challenge of knowledge retention within networks. This research adopts Social Exchange Theory in order to develop the theoretical underpinning and data interpretation. The paper also presents an explanatory model to inform theorists and practitioners on how to improve knowledge retention in networks. A qualitative approach was used through an ethnographic lens consisting of 18 months participant observation study that produced 28 semi-structured interviews. The study also utilised data from network archive network spanning two years. This paper argues that knowledge shared in the networks largely remained inside them and that less knowledge was shared with networked organisations making the network knowledge "ontologically" separate from knowledge created in organisations. The data also revealed that 'boundary spanners' found it difficult to share knowledge between their formally contracted organisation and the informal network, due to issues related to trust and unbalanced reciprocal exchanges. Our investigation of knowledge sharing in those networks demonstrates the difficulty in retaining it on a network level due to blurring organisational boundaries and the temporary nature of such networks.

AB - Taking a constructivist view of knowledge where it is viewed as a 'process of knowing', the literature on knowledge sharing assumes that it can be retained through embedding within institutional routines, structures, and systems. However, this concept is challenged in the context of informal organisational networks where membership is voluntary, temporary and organisationally unsanctioned. Such challenges have predominately focused around: 1) behavioural aspects including organisational and individual defence mechanisms to protect knowledge and opportunistic behaviours such as free-riding; or 2) social aspects including lack of mutual trust and asymmetric power relations. We therefore consider the mechanisms and theoretical underpinning of socially constructed knowledge across a number of informal networks. This paper investigates the challenges to knowledge retention in knowledge-sharing networks, reporting on data collected from a case study of four informal organisational networks in the UK (two photography networks; women entrepreneurship network; and a construction network). There is a significant amount of literature addressing such challenges on an organisational level, however, less research exists on the network level. In particular, the challenge of knowledge retention within networks. This research adopts Social Exchange Theory in order to develop the theoretical underpinning and data interpretation. The paper also presents an explanatory model to inform theorists and practitioners on how to improve knowledge retention in networks. A qualitative approach was used through an ethnographic lens consisting of 18 months participant observation study that produced 28 semi-structured interviews. The study also utilised data from network archive network spanning two years. This paper argues that knowledge shared in the networks largely remained inside them and that less knowledge was shared with networked organisations making the network knowledge "ontologically" separate from knowledge created in organisations. The data also revealed that 'boundary spanners' found it difficult to share knowledge between their formally contracted organisation and the informal network, due to issues related to trust and unbalanced reciprocal exchanges. Our investigation of knowledge sharing in those networks demonstrates the difficulty in retaining it on a network level due to blurring organisational boundaries and the temporary nature of such networks.

KW - Boundary spanners

KW - Inter-organisational learning

KW - Knowledge retention

KW - Knowledge sharing

KW - Networks

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85035342940&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Conference contribution

VL - 1

SP - 1

EP - 7

BT - Proceedings of the 18th European Conference on Knowledge Management, ECKM 2017

PB - Academic Conferences Limited

ER -

Abualqumboz M, Reid I, Papalexi M, Bamford D. Can knowledge be retained in informal organisational networks? In Proceedings of the 18th European Conference on Knowledge Management, ECKM 2017. Vol. 1. Academic Conferences Limited. 2017. p. 1-7