Configural and featural information in facial-composite images

Charlie D. Frowd, Sharrome Jones, Cristina Fodarella, Faye Skelton, Steve Fields, Anna Williams, John E. Marsh, Rachel Thorley, Laura Nelson, Leah Greenwood, Louisa Date, Kevin Kearley, Alex H. McIntyre, Peter J B Hancock

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

12 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Eyewitnesses are often invited to construct a facial composite, an image created of the person they saw commit a crime that is used by law enforcement to locate criminal suspects. In the current paper, the effectiveness of composite images was investigated from traditional feature systems (E-FIT and PRO-fit), where participants (face constructors) selected individual features to build the face, and a more recent holistic system (EvoFIT), where they 'evolved' a composite by repeatedly selecting from arrays of complete faces. Further participants attempted to name these composites when seen as an unaltered image, or when blurred, rotated, linearly stretched or converted to a photographic negative. All of the manipulations tested reduced correct naming of the composites overall except (i) for a low level of blur, for which naming improved for holistic composites but reduced for feature composites, and (ii) for 100% linear stretch, for which a substantial naming advantage was observed. Results also indicated that both featural (facial elements) and configural (feature spacing) information were useful for recognition in both types of composite system, but highly-detailed information was more accurate in the feature-based than in the holistic method. The naming advantage of linear stretch was replicated using a forensically more-practical procedure with observers viewing an unaltered composite sideways. The work is valuable to police practitioners and designers of facial-composite systems.

LanguageEnglish
Pages215-227
Number of pages13
JournalScience and Justice
Volume54
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2014

Fingerprint

Law Enforcement
Police
Crime
Names

Cite this

Frowd, C. D., Jones, S., Fodarella, C., Skelton, F., Fields, S., Williams, A., ... Hancock, P. J. B. (2014). Configural and featural information in facial-composite images. Science and Justice, 54(3), 215-227. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scijus.2013.11.001
Frowd, Charlie D. ; Jones, Sharrome ; Fodarella, Cristina ; Skelton, Faye ; Fields, Steve ; Williams, Anna ; Marsh, John E. ; Thorley, Rachel ; Nelson, Laura ; Greenwood, Leah ; Date, Louisa ; Kearley, Kevin ; McIntyre, Alex H. ; Hancock, Peter J B. / Configural and featural information in facial-composite images. In: Science and Justice. 2014 ; Vol. 54, No. 3. pp. 215-227.
@article{4d8610f03ae24f01883e5afe1c1710b3,
title = "Configural and featural information in facial-composite images",
abstract = "Eyewitnesses are often invited to construct a facial composite, an image created of the person they saw commit a crime that is used by law enforcement to locate criminal suspects. In the current paper, the effectiveness of composite images was investigated from traditional feature systems (E-FIT and PRO-fit), where participants (face constructors) selected individual features to build the face, and a more recent holistic system (EvoFIT), where they 'evolved' a composite by repeatedly selecting from arrays of complete faces. Further participants attempted to name these composites when seen as an unaltered image, or when blurred, rotated, linearly stretched or converted to a photographic negative. All of the manipulations tested reduced correct naming of the composites overall except (i) for a low level of blur, for which naming improved for holistic composites but reduced for feature composites, and (ii) for 100{\%} linear stretch, for which a substantial naming advantage was observed. Results also indicated that both featural (facial elements) and configural (feature spacing) information were useful for recognition in both types of composite system, but highly-detailed information was more accurate in the feature-based than in the holistic method. The naming advantage of linear stretch was replicated using a forensically more-practical procedure with observers viewing an unaltered composite sideways. The work is valuable to police practitioners and designers of facial-composite systems.",
keywords = "Configural, Crime, Criminal suspects, Facial composite, Feature, Identification",
author = "Frowd, {Charlie D.} and Sharrome Jones and Cristina Fodarella and Faye Skelton and Steve Fields and Anna Williams and Marsh, {John E.} and Rachel Thorley and Laura Nelson and Leah Greenwood and Louisa Date and Kevin Kearley and McIntyre, {Alex H.} and Hancock, {Peter J B}",
year = "2014",
doi = "10.1016/j.scijus.2013.11.001",
language = "English",
volume = "54",
pages = "215--227",
journal = "Science and Justice - Journal of the Forensic Science Society",
issn = "1355-0306",
publisher = "Forensic Science Society",
number = "3",

}

Frowd, CD, Jones, S, Fodarella, C, Skelton, F, Fields, S, Williams, A, Marsh, JE, Thorley, R, Nelson, L, Greenwood, L, Date, L, Kearley, K, McIntyre, AH & Hancock, PJB 2014, 'Configural and featural information in facial-composite images', Science and Justice, vol. 54, no. 3, pp. 215-227. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scijus.2013.11.001

Configural and featural information in facial-composite images. / Frowd, Charlie D.; Jones, Sharrome; Fodarella, Cristina; Skelton, Faye; Fields, Steve; Williams, Anna; Marsh, John E.; Thorley, Rachel; Nelson, Laura; Greenwood, Leah; Date, Louisa; Kearley, Kevin; McIntyre, Alex H.; Hancock, Peter J B.

In: Science and Justice, Vol. 54, No. 3, 2014, p. 215-227.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Configural and featural information in facial-composite images

AU - Frowd, Charlie D.

AU - Jones, Sharrome

AU - Fodarella, Cristina

AU - Skelton, Faye

AU - Fields, Steve

AU - Williams, Anna

AU - Marsh, John E.

AU - Thorley, Rachel

AU - Nelson, Laura

AU - Greenwood, Leah

AU - Date, Louisa

AU - Kearley, Kevin

AU - McIntyre, Alex H.

AU - Hancock, Peter J B

PY - 2014

Y1 - 2014

N2 - Eyewitnesses are often invited to construct a facial composite, an image created of the person they saw commit a crime that is used by law enforcement to locate criminal suspects. In the current paper, the effectiveness of composite images was investigated from traditional feature systems (E-FIT and PRO-fit), where participants (face constructors) selected individual features to build the face, and a more recent holistic system (EvoFIT), where they 'evolved' a composite by repeatedly selecting from arrays of complete faces. Further participants attempted to name these composites when seen as an unaltered image, or when blurred, rotated, linearly stretched or converted to a photographic negative. All of the manipulations tested reduced correct naming of the composites overall except (i) for a low level of blur, for which naming improved for holistic composites but reduced for feature composites, and (ii) for 100% linear stretch, for which a substantial naming advantage was observed. Results also indicated that both featural (facial elements) and configural (feature spacing) information were useful for recognition in both types of composite system, but highly-detailed information was more accurate in the feature-based than in the holistic method. The naming advantage of linear stretch was replicated using a forensically more-practical procedure with observers viewing an unaltered composite sideways. The work is valuable to police practitioners and designers of facial-composite systems.

AB - Eyewitnesses are often invited to construct a facial composite, an image created of the person they saw commit a crime that is used by law enforcement to locate criminal suspects. In the current paper, the effectiveness of composite images was investigated from traditional feature systems (E-FIT and PRO-fit), where participants (face constructors) selected individual features to build the face, and a more recent holistic system (EvoFIT), where they 'evolved' a composite by repeatedly selecting from arrays of complete faces. Further participants attempted to name these composites when seen as an unaltered image, or when blurred, rotated, linearly stretched or converted to a photographic negative. All of the manipulations tested reduced correct naming of the composites overall except (i) for a low level of blur, for which naming improved for holistic composites but reduced for feature composites, and (ii) for 100% linear stretch, for which a substantial naming advantage was observed. Results also indicated that both featural (facial elements) and configural (feature spacing) information were useful for recognition in both types of composite system, but highly-detailed information was more accurate in the feature-based than in the holistic method. The naming advantage of linear stretch was replicated using a forensically more-practical procedure with observers viewing an unaltered composite sideways. The work is valuable to police practitioners and designers of facial-composite systems.

KW - Configural

KW - Crime

KW - Criminal suspects

KW - Facial composite

KW - Feature

KW - Identification

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84899946824&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.scijus.2013.11.001

DO - 10.1016/j.scijus.2013.11.001

M3 - Article

VL - 54

SP - 215

EP - 227

JO - Science and Justice - Journal of the Forensic Science Society

T2 - Science and Justice - Journal of the Forensic Science Society

JF - Science and Justice - Journal of the Forensic Science Society

SN - 1355-0306

IS - 3

ER -