Ecological Risk Assessment of Agricultural Soils for the Definition of Soil Screening Values: A Comparison Between Substance-Based and Matrix-Based Approaches

Stefano Vanin, Alberto Pivato, Maria Cristina Lavagnolo, Barbara Manachini, Roberto Raga, Giovanni Beggio

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The Italian legislation on contaminated soils does not include the Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA) and this deficiency has important consequences for the sustainable management of agricultural soils. The present research compares the results of two ERA procedures applied to agriculture (i) one based on the “substance-based” approach and (ii) a second based on the “matrix-based” approach. In the former the soil screening values (SVs) for individual substances were derived according to institutional foreign guidelines. In the latter, the SVs characterizing the whole-matrix were derived originally by the authors by means of experimental activity. The results indicate that the “matrix-based” approach can be efficiently implemented in the Italian legislation for the ERA of agricultural soils. This method, if compared to the institutionalized “substance based” approach is (i) comparable in economic terms and in testing time, (ii) is site specific and assesses the real effect of the investigated soil on a battery of bioassays, (iii) accounts for phenomena that may radically modify the exposure of the organisms to the totality of contaminants and (iv) can be considered sufficiently conservative.

LanguageEnglish
Article numbere00284
JournalHeliyon
Volume3
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 3 Apr 2017

Fingerprint

agricultural soil
risk assessment
matrix
legislation
soil
bioassay
agriculture
comparison
screening
pollutant
economics

Cite this

Vanin, Stefano ; Pivato, Alberto ; Lavagnolo, Maria Cristina ; Manachini, Barbara ; Raga, Roberto ; Beggio, Giovanni. / Ecological Risk Assessment of Agricultural Soils for the Definition of Soil Screening Values : A Comparison Between Substance-Based and Matrix-Based Approaches. In: Heliyon. 2017 ; Vol. 3, No. 4.
@article{5e65f6134a6f40ab8251bc3c0cdbadeb,
title = "Ecological Risk Assessment of Agricultural Soils for the Definition of Soil Screening Values: A Comparison Between Substance-Based and Matrix-Based Approaches",
abstract = "The Italian legislation on contaminated soils does not include the Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA) and this deficiency has important consequences for the sustainable management of agricultural soils. The present research compares the results of two ERA procedures applied to agriculture (i) one based on the “substance-based” approach and (ii) a second based on the “matrix-based” approach. In the former the soil screening values (SVs) for individual substances were derived according to institutional foreign guidelines. In the latter, the SVs characterizing the whole-matrix were derived originally by the authors by means of experimental activity. The results indicate that the “matrix-based” approach can be efficiently implemented in the Italian legislation for the ERA of agricultural soils. This method, if compared to the institutionalized “substance based” approach is (i) comparable in economic terms and in testing time, (ii) is site specific and assesses the real effect of the investigated soil on a battery of bioassays, (iii) accounts for phenomena that may radically modify the exposure of the organisms to the totality of contaminants and (iv) can be considered sufficiently conservative.",
keywords = "Environmental science",
author = "Stefano Vanin and Alberto Pivato and Lavagnolo, {Maria Cristina} and Barbara Manachini and Roberto Raga and Giovanni Beggio",
year = "2017",
month = "4",
day = "3",
doi = "10.1016/j.heliyon.2017.e00284",
language = "English",
volume = "3",
journal = "Heliyon",
issn = "2405-8440",
publisher = "Elsevier BV",
number = "4",

}

Ecological Risk Assessment of Agricultural Soils for the Definition of Soil Screening Values : A Comparison Between Substance-Based and Matrix-Based Approaches. / Vanin, Stefano; Pivato, Alberto; Lavagnolo, Maria Cristina; Manachini, Barbara; Raga, Roberto; Beggio, Giovanni.

In: Heliyon, Vol. 3, No. 4, e00284, 03.04.2017.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Ecological Risk Assessment of Agricultural Soils for the Definition of Soil Screening Values

T2 - Heliyon

AU - Vanin, Stefano

AU - Pivato, Alberto

AU - Lavagnolo, Maria Cristina

AU - Manachini, Barbara

AU - Raga, Roberto

AU - Beggio, Giovanni

PY - 2017/4/3

Y1 - 2017/4/3

N2 - The Italian legislation on contaminated soils does not include the Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA) and this deficiency has important consequences for the sustainable management of agricultural soils. The present research compares the results of two ERA procedures applied to agriculture (i) one based on the “substance-based” approach and (ii) a second based on the “matrix-based” approach. In the former the soil screening values (SVs) for individual substances were derived according to institutional foreign guidelines. In the latter, the SVs characterizing the whole-matrix were derived originally by the authors by means of experimental activity. The results indicate that the “matrix-based” approach can be efficiently implemented in the Italian legislation for the ERA of agricultural soils. This method, if compared to the institutionalized “substance based” approach is (i) comparable in economic terms and in testing time, (ii) is site specific and assesses the real effect of the investigated soil on a battery of bioassays, (iii) accounts for phenomena that may radically modify the exposure of the organisms to the totality of contaminants and (iv) can be considered sufficiently conservative.

AB - The Italian legislation on contaminated soils does not include the Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA) and this deficiency has important consequences for the sustainable management of agricultural soils. The present research compares the results of two ERA procedures applied to agriculture (i) one based on the “substance-based” approach and (ii) a second based on the “matrix-based” approach. In the former the soil screening values (SVs) for individual substances were derived according to institutional foreign guidelines. In the latter, the SVs characterizing the whole-matrix were derived originally by the authors by means of experimental activity. The results indicate that the “matrix-based” approach can be efficiently implemented in the Italian legislation for the ERA of agricultural soils. This method, if compared to the institutionalized “substance based” approach is (i) comparable in economic terms and in testing time, (ii) is site specific and assesses the real effect of the investigated soil on a battery of bioassays, (iii) accounts for phenomena that may radically modify the exposure of the organisms to the totality of contaminants and (iv) can be considered sufficiently conservative.

KW - Environmental science

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85016638402&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.heliyon.2017.e00284

DO - 10.1016/j.heliyon.2017.e00284

M3 - Article

VL - 3

JO - Heliyon

JF - Heliyon

SN - 2405-8440

IS - 4

M1 - e00284

ER -