Embedded dialogue and dreams: The worlds and accessibility relations of Inception

Jane Lugea

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In this article, Text World Theory (Gavins, 2007; Werth, 1999) and Ryan's model of fictional worlds (1991a, 1991b) are both applied to Nolan's blockbuster film, Inception (2010) to explore the multi-layered architecture of the narrative. The opening two scenes of Nolan's screenplay are analysed using Text World Theory, with particular attention to the embedded nature of character dialogue, or, more generally, 'represented discourse' (Herman, 1993), otherwise known as Direct Speech (Leech and Short, 2007). Based on this analysis, I suggest a modification to the way in which Text World Theory deals with represented discourse, which improves the framework's applicability to all text types. Moving from the micro-analysis of the screenplay text, to a macro-analysis of the film narrative as a whole, I outline the various different worlds that make up the reality, dream and 'limbo' layers in the film, explaining how most of the action takes place at a remove from the world at the centre of the textual system. I use Deictic Shift Theory's terms PUSH and POP (Galbraith, 1995) to describe the movements between the ontological layers of the narrative and suggest that these terms are better suited to describe hierarchies of ontology rather than horizontal deictic shifts. Ryan's taxonomy of accessibility relations is used to describe the ways in which the film differs from reality, as well as the ways in which the dreams differ from the internal reality of the film. The complex ontological structure and asymmetric accessibility relations between the worlds are ascribed as the reason for many viewers' difficulty in processing the film's narrative. With its attention to discourse-world factors, Text World Theory is then used to account for the myriad of reactions to Inception - as expressed on online discussion forums - which range from engagement and enjoyment to frustration and resistance.

LanguageEnglish
Pages133-153
Number of pages21
JournalLanguage and Literature
Volume22
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - May 2013

Fingerprint

dialogue
narrative
discourse
frustration
taxonomy
ontology
Accessibility
Discourse
Screenplay
Deictic
Layer
Ontological

Cite this

@article{e69cc445b5a84ba8b19b2f8c03fe0d28,
title = "Embedded dialogue and dreams: The worlds and accessibility relations of Inception",
abstract = "In this article, Text World Theory (Gavins, 2007; Werth, 1999) and Ryan's model of fictional worlds (1991a, 1991b) are both applied to Nolan's blockbuster film, Inception (2010) to explore the multi-layered architecture of the narrative. The opening two scenes of Nolan's screenplay are analysed using Text World Theory, with particular attention to the embedded nature of character dialogue, or, more generally, 'represented discourse' (Herman, 1993), otherwise known as Direct Speech (Leech and Short, 2007). Based on this analysis, I suggest a modification to the way in which Text World Theory deals with represented discourse, which improves the framework's applicability to all text types. Moving from the micro-analysis of the screenplay text, to a macro-analysis of the film narrative as a whole, I outline the various different worlds that make up the reality, dream and 'limbo' layers in the film, explaining how most of the action takes place at a remove from the world at the centre of the textual system. I use Deictic Shift Theory's terms PUSH and POP (Galbraith, 1995) to describe the movements between the ontological layers of the narrative and suggest that these terms are better suited to describe hierarchies of ontology rather than horizontal deictic shifts. Ryan's taxonomy of accessibility relations is used to describe the ways in which the film differs from reality, as well as the ways in which the dreams differ from the internal reality of the film. The complex ontological structure and asymmetric accessibility relations between the worlds are ascribed as the reason for many viewers' difficulty in processing the film's narrative. With its attention to discourse-world factors, Text World Theory is then used to account for the myriad of reactions to Inception - as expressed on online discussion forums - which range from engagement and enjoyment to frustration and resistance.",
keywords = "Christopher Nolan, Direct Speech, fictional worlds, Inception, narrative, possible worlds, represented discourse, screenplay, Text World Theory",
author = "Jane Lugea",
year = "2013",
month = "5",
doi = "10.1177/0963947013489618",
language = "English",
volume = "22",
pages = "133--153",
journal = "Language and Literature",
issn = "0963-9470",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Ltd",
number = "2",

}

Embedded dialogue and dreams : The worlds and accessibility relations of Inception. / Lugea, Jane.

In: Language and Literature, Vol. 22, No. 2, 05.2013, p. 133-153.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Embedded dialogue and dreams

T2 - Language and Literature

AU - Lugea, Jane

PY - 2013/5

Y1 - 2013/5

N2 - In this article, Text World Theory (Gavins, 2007; Werth, 1999) and Ryan's model of fictional worlds (1991a, 1991b) are both applied to Nolan's blockbuster film, Inception (2010) to explore the multi-layered architecture of the narrative. The opening two scenes of Nolan's screenplay are analysed using Text World Theory, with particular attention to the embedded nature of character dialogue, or, more generally, 'represented discourse' (Herman, 1993), otherwise known as Direct Speech (Leech and Short, 2007). Based on this analysis, I suggest a modification to the way in which Text World Theory deals with represented discourse, which improves the framework's applicability to all text types. Moving from the micro-analysis of the screenplay text, to a macro-analysis of the film narrative as a whole, I outline the various different worlds that make up the reality, dream and 'limbo' layers in the film, explaining how most of the action takes place at a remove from the world at the centre of the textual system. I use Deictic Shift Theory's terms PUSH and POP (Galbraith, 1995) to describe the movements between the ontological layers of the narrative and suggest that these terms are better suited to describe hierarchies of ontology rather than horizontal deictic shifts. Ryan's taxonomy of accessibility relations is used to describe the ways in which the film differs from reality, as well as the ways in which the dreams differ from the internal reality of the film. The complex ontological structure and asymmetric accessibility relations between the worlds are ascribed as the reason for many viewers' difficulty in processing the film's narrative. With its attention to discourse-world factors, Text World Theory is then used to account for the myriad of reactions to Inception - as expressed on online discussion forums - which range from engagement and enjoyment to frustration and resistance.

AB - In this article, Text World Theory (Gavins, 2007; Werth, 1999) and Ryan's model of fictional worlds (1991a, 1991b) are both applied to Nolan's blockbuster film, Inception (2010) to explore the multi-layered architecture of the narrative. The opening two scenes of Nolan's screenplay are analysed using Text World Theory, with particular attention to the embedded nature of character dialogue, or, more generally, 'represented discourse' (Herman, 1993), otherwise known as Direct Speech (Leech and Short, 2007). Based on this analysis, I suggest a modification to the way in which Text World Theory deals with represented discourse, which improves the framework's applicability to all text types. Moving from the micro-analysis of the screenplay text, to a macro-analysis of the film narrative as a whole, I outline the various different worlds that make up the reality, dream and 'limbo' layers in the film, explaining how most of the action takes place at a remove from the world at the centre of the textual system. I use Deictic Shift Theory's terms PUSH and POP (Galbraith, 1995) to describe the movements between the ontological layers of the narrative and suggest that these terms are better suited to describe hierarchies of ontology rather than horizontal deictic shifts. Ryan's taxonomy of accessibility relations is used to describe the ways in which the film differs from reality, as well as the ways in which the dreams differ from the internal reality of the film. The complex ontological structure and asymmetric accessibility relations between the worlds are ascribed as the reason for many viewers' difficulty in processing the film's narrative. With its attention to discourse-world factors, Text World Theory is then used to account for the myriad of reactions to Inception - as expressed on online discussion forums - which range from engagement and enjoyment to frustration and resistance.

KW - Christopher Nolan

KW - Direct Speech

KW - fictional worlds

KW - Inception

KW - narrative

KW - possible worlds

KW - represented discourse

KW - screenplay

KW - Text World Theory

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84877955037&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/0963947013489618

DO - 10.1177/0963947013489618

M3 - Article

VL - 22

SP - 133

EP - 153

JO - Language and Literature

JF - Language and Literature

SN - 0963-9470

IS - 2

ER -