From interpretation to action

unique adequacy as a common standard for the evaluation of research in the built environment

Clementinah Rooke, John A. Rooke

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Abstract

The practice of ethnography faces severe obstacles in construction management and design. Erroneous methodological assumptions that have been largely superseded in other disciplines still hold sway in the field. Recently Dainty (2008) bemoaned the failure of construction management researchers to adopt what he terms ‘mixed methodologies’. He places less emphasis on his finding that research adopting purely qualitative methods features even less. However, the finding is clear: of a sample of 107 papers from Construction Management and Economics, 76 (71 per cent) used purely quantitative methods. The reason is not hard to find. In the same volume in which Dainty published his findings, Runeson and Skitmore offered the following advice:

To some, reality is governed by a set of rules of how variables inter-relate and science aims to uncover these rules so that we can understand and describe, through our theories, an objective reality that exists independent of us. To others, reality is subjective, a social construct, changing depending on who views it and existing only in our minds as our constructs.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationEthnographic Research in the Construction Industry
EditorsSarah Pink, Dylan Tutt, Andrew Dainty
Place of PublicationLondon
PublisherRoutledge
Chapter9
Pages141-159
Number of pages19
Edition1st
ISBN (Electronic)9780203834671
ISBN (Print)9780415603430, 9781138820142
Publication statusPublished - 28 Aug 2012
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

interpretation
evaluation
management
quantitative method
qualitative method
ethnography
methodology
science
economics

Cite this

Rooke, C., & Rooke, J. A. (2012). From interpretation to action: unique adequacy as a common standard for the evaluation of research in the built environment. In S. Pink, D. Tutt, & A. Dainty (Eds.), Ethnographic Research in the Construction Industry (1st ed., pp. 141-159). London: Routledge.
Rooke, Clementinah ; Rooke, John A. / From interpretation to action : unique adequacy as a common standard for the evaluation of research in the built environment. Ethnographic Research in the Construction Industry. editor / Sarah Pink ; Dylan Tutt ; Andrew Dainty. 1st. ed. London : Routledge, 2012. pp. 141-159
@inbook{1168711f5b864d72a20d15fc5cff414e,
title = "From interpretation to action: unique adequacy as a common standard for the evaluation of research in the built environment",
abstract = "The practice of ethnography faces severe obstacles in construction management and design. Erroneous methodological assumptions that have been largely superseded in other disciplines still hold sway in the field. Recently Dainty (2008) bemoaned the failure of construction management researchers to adopt what he terms ‘mixed methodologies’. He places less emphasis on his finding that research adopting purely qualitative methods features even less. However, the finding is clear: of a sample of 107 papers from Construction Management and Economics, 76 (71 per cent) used purely quantitative methods. The reason is not hard to find. In the same volume in which Dainty published his findings, Runeson and Skitmore offered the following advice:To some, reality is governed by a set of rules of how variables inter-relate and science aims to uncover these rules so that we can understand and describe, through our theories, an objective reality that exists independent of us. To others, reality is subjective, a social construct, changing depending on who views it and existing only in our minds as our constructs.",
keywords = "ethnographic, construction industry, built environment",
author = "Clementinah Rooke and Rooke, {John A.}",
year = "2012",
month = "8",
day = "28",
language = "English",
isbn = "9780415603430",
pages = "141--159",
editor = "Pink, {Sarah } and Tutt, {Dylan } and Dainty, {Andrew }",
booktitle = "Ethnographic Research in the Construction Industry",
publisher = "Routledge",
edition = "1st",

}

Rooke, C & Rooke, JA 2012, From interpretation to action: unique adequacy as a common standard for the evaluation of research in the built environment. in S Pink, D Tutt & A Dainty (eds), Ethnographic Research in the Construction Industry. 1st edn, Routledge, London, pp. 141-159.

From interpretation to action : unique adequacy as a common standard for the evaluation of research in the built environment. / Rooke, Clementinah; Rooke, John A.

Ethnographic Research in the Construction Industry. ed. / Sarah Pink; Dylan Tutt; Andrew Dainty. 1st. ed. London : Routledge, 2012. p. 141-159.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - From interpretation to action

T2 - unique adequacy as a common standard for the evaluation of research in the built environment

AU - Rooke, Clementinah

AU - Rooke, John A.

PY - 2012/8/28

Y1 - 2012/8/28

N2 - The practice of ethnography faces severe obstacles in construction management and design. Erroneous methodological assumptions that have been largely superseded in other disciplines still hold sway in the field. Recently Dainty (2008) bemoaned the failure of construction management researchers to adopt what he terms ‘mixed methodologies’. He places less emphasis on his finding that research adopting purely qualitative methods features even less. However, the finding is clear: of a sample of 107 papers from Construction Management and Economics, 76 (71 per cent) used purely quantitative methods. The reason is not hard to find. In the same volume in which Dainty published his findings, Runeson and Skitmore offered the following advice:To some, reality is governed by a set of rules of how variables inter-relate and science aims to uncover these rules so that we can understand and describe, through our theories, an objective reality that exists independent of us. To others, reality is subjective, a social construct, changing depending on who views it and existing only in our minds as our constructs.

AB - The practice of ethnography faces severe obstacles in construction management and design. Erroneous methodological assumptions that have been largely superseded in other disciplines still hold sway in the field. Recently Dainty (2008) bemoaned the failure of construction management researchers to adopt what he terms ‘mixed methodologies’. He places less emphasis on his finding that research adopting purely qualitative methods features even less. However, the finding is clear: of a sample of 107 papers from Construction Management and Economics, 76 (71 per cent) used purely quantitative methods. The reason is not hard to find. In the same volume in which Dainty published his findings, Runeson and Skitmore offered the following advice:To some, reality is governed by a set of rules of how variables inter-relate and science aims to uncover these rules so that we can understand and describe, through our theories, an objective reality that exists independent of us. To others, reality is subjective, a social construct, changing depending on who views it and existing only in our minds as our constructs.

KW - ethnographic

KW - construction industry

KW - built environment

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9780415603430

SN - 9781138820142

SP - 141

EP - 159

BT - Ethnographic Research in the Construction Industry

A2 - Pink, Sarah

A2 - Tutt, Dylan

A2 - Dainty, Andrew

PB - Routledge

CY - London

ER -

Rooke C, Rooke JA. From interpretation to action: unique adequacy as a common standard for the evaluation of research in the built environment. In Pink S, Tutt D, Dainty A, editors, Ethnographic Research in the Construction Industry. 1st ed. London: Routledge. 2012. p. 141-159