Gender associations for musical instruments in nursery children

the effect of sound and image

Nigel A. Marshall, Kagari Shibazaki

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This paper reports on the results of a study carried out with 105 children, aged between three and four years in three nursery units in London and Surrey, UK. The aim of this study was to explore the level of association which young children have between various musical instruments, musical styles and a particular gender. However, we also aimed to investigate if and how any gender association could be affected through the addition of an image of the featured musical instrument along with the sound of the instrument being played. The study had two conditions. In condition one, children were played 14 short (10 seconds) musical excerpts, 7 classical pieces and 7 jazz/pop pieces on 7 musical instruments, which previous research had identified as having strong associations with either males or females; namely flute, violin, piano, guitar, trumpet and drums. In this condition, the children were also given the name and shown an image of the instrument featured in the excerpt. In condition two, participants heard only the sound of the instrument and were neither given a name nor shown an image. Children expressed their gender association through the use of small playing cards, each featuring the cartoon image of either a boy or girl. Our results suggested that gender associations do exist in very young children, many of whom have spent a relatively short time in the education system and the presence of an image, alongside the sound of an instrument can in some instances dramatically change the gender they assign to the individual instrument.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)406-420
Number of pages15
JournalMusic Education Research
Volume15
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2013
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

gender
jazz
Musical Instruments
Sound
cartoon
education system
Names
Education System
Boys
Trumpet
Violin
Surrey
Flute
Jazz
Drum
Cartoon
Very Young children
Guitar
Musical Style
Young children

Cite this

@article{726ebc7c6ef345d397e5f6b8fa6d1596,
title = "Gender associations for musical instruments in nursery children: the effect of sound and image",
abstract = "This paper reports on the results of a study carried out with 105 children, aged between three and four years in three nursery units in London and Surrey, UK. The aim of this study was to explore the level of association which young children have between various musical instruments, musical styles and a particular gender. However, we also aimed to investigate if and how any gender association could be affected through the addition of an image of the featured musical instrument along with the sound of the instrument being played. The study had two conditions. In condition one, children were played 14 short (10 seconds) musical excerpts, 7 classical pieces and 7 jazz/pop pieces on 7 musical instruments, which previous research had identified as having strong associations with either males or females; namely flute, violin, piano, guitar, trumpet and drums. In this condition, the children were also given the name and shown an image of the instrument featured in the excerpt. In condition two, participants heard only the sound of the instrument and were neither given a name nor shown an image. Children expressed their gender association through the use of small playing cards, each featuring the cartoon image of either a boy or girl. Our results suggested that gender associations do exist in very young children, many of whom have spent a relatively short time in the education system and the presence of an image, alongside the sound of an instrument can in some instances dramatically change the gender they assign to the individual instrument.",
keywords = "Gender stereotypes, Musical instruments, Musical style, Gender associations, Early childhood",
author = "Marshall, {Nigel A.} and Kagari Shibazaki",
year = "2013",
doi = "10.1080/14613808.2013.826641",
language = "English",
volume = "15",
pages = "406--420",
journal = "Music Education Research",
issn = "1461-3808",
publisher = "Routledge",
number = "4",

}

Gender associations for musical instruments in nursery children : the effect of sound and image. / Marshall, Nigel A.; Shibazaki, Kagari.

In: Music Education Research, Vol. 15, No. 4, 2013, p. 406-420.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Gender associations for musical instruments in nursery children

T2 - the effect of sound and image

AU - Marshall, Nigel A.

AU - Shibazaki, Kagari

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - This paper reports on the results of a study carried out with 105 children, aged between three and four years in three nursery units in London and Surrey, UK. The aim of this study was to explore the level of association which young children have between various musical instruments, musical styles and a particular gender. However, we also aimed to investigate if and how any gender association could be affected through the addition of an image of the featured musical instrument along with the sound of the instrument being played. The study had two conditions. In condition one, children were played 14 short (10 seconds) musical excerpts, 7 classical pieces and 7 jazz/pop pieces on 7 musical instruments, which previous research had identified as having strong associations with either males or females; namely flute, violin, piano, guitar, trumpet and drums. In this condition, the children were also given the name and shown an image of the instrument featured in the excerpt. In condition two, participants heard only the sound of the instrument and were neither given a name nor shown an image. Children expressed their gender association through the use of small playing cards, each featuring the cartoon image of either a boy or girl. Our results suggested that gender associations do exist in very young children, many of whom have spent a relatively short time in the education system and the presence of an image, alongside the sound of an instrument can in some instances dramatically change the gender they assign to the individual instrument.

AB - This paper reports on the results of a study carried out with 105 children, aged between three and four years in three nursery units in London and Surrey, UK. The aim of this study was to explore the level of association which young children have between various musical instruments, musical styles and a particular gender. However, we also aimed to investigate if and how any gender association could be affected through the addition of an image of the featured musical instrument along with the sound of the instrument being played. The study had two conditions. In condition one, children were played 14 short (10 seconds) musical excerpts, 7 classical pieces and 7 jazz/pop pieces on 7 musical instruments, which previous research had identified as having strong associations with either males or females; namely flute, violin, piano, guitar, trumpet and drums. In this condition, the children were also given the name and shown an image of the instrument featured in the excerpt. In condition two, participants heard only the sound of the instrument and were neither given a name nor shown an image. Children expressed their gender association through the use of small playing cards, each featuring the cartoon image of either a boy or girl. Our results suggested that gender associations do exist in very young children, many of whom have spent a relatively short time in the education system and the presence of an image, alongside the sound of an instrument can in some instances dramatically change the gender they assign to the individual instrument.

KW - Gender stereotypes

KW - Musical instruments

KW - Musical style

KW - Gender associations

KW - Early childhood

U2 - 10.1080/14613808.2013.826641

DO - 10.1080/14613808.2013.826641

M3 - Article

VL - 15

SP - 406

EP - 420

JO - Music Education Research

JF - Music Education Research

SN - 1461-3808

IS - 4

ER -