Gendered and Social Hierarchies in Problem Representation and Policy Processes

''Domestic Violence'' in Finland and Scotland

Jeff Hearn, Linda McKie

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

32 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This article identifies and critiques presumptions about gender and violence that continue to frame and inform the processes of policy formation and implementation on domestic violence. It also deconstructs the agendered nature of policy as gendered, multilevel individual and collective action. Drawing on comparative illustrative material from Finland and Scotland, we discuss how national policies and discourses emphasize physical forms of violence, place the onus on the agency of women, and encourage a narrow conceptualization of violence in relationships. The two countries do this in somewhat comparable, though different ways operating within distinct national gender contexts. The complex interweaving of masculinities, violence, and cultures, although recognized in many debates, is seemingly marginalized from dominant discourses, policy, and legal processes. Despite growth in critical studies on men, there is little attempt made to problematize the gendered nature of violence. Rather, policy and service outcomes reflect processes through which individualized and masculine discourses frame ideas, discourses, and policy work. Women experiencing violence are constructed as victims and potential survivors of violence, although the social and gendered hierarchies evident in policies and services result in longer-term inequities and suffering for women and their dependents.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)136-158
Number of pages23
JournalViolence Against Women
Volume16
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2010
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

domestic violence
Finland
violence
discourse
legal process
gender
collective behavior
masculinity

Cite this

@article{b78ecc6874bf441fb1c665a4898fa79c,
title = "Gendered and Social Hierarchies in Problem Representation and Policy Processes: ''Domestic Violence'' in Finland and Scotland",
abstract = "This article identifies and critiques presumptions about gender and violence that continue to frame and inform the processes of policy formation and implementation on domestic violence. It also deconstructs the agendered nature of policy as gendered, multilevel individual and collective action. Drawing on comparative illustrative material from Finland and Scotland, we discuss how national policies and discourses emphasize physical forms of violence, place the onus on the agency of women, and encourage a narrow conceptualization of violence in relationships. The two countries do this in somewhat comparable, though different ways operating within distinct national gender contexts. The complex interweaving of masculinities, violence, and cultures, although recognized in many debates, is seemingly marginalized from dominant discourses, policy, and legal processes. Despite growth in critical studies on men, there is little attempt made to problematize the gendered nature of violence. Rather, policy and service outcomes reflect processes through which individualized and masculine discourses frame ideas, discourses, and policy work. Women experiencing violence are constructed as victims and potential survivors of violence, although the social and gendered hierarchies evident in policies and services result in longer-term inequities and suffering for women and their dependents.",
keywords = "Domestic violence, Finland, Gender, Policy, Problem representation, Scotland",
author = "Jeff Hearn and Linda McKie",
year = "2010",
doi = "10.1177/1077801209355185",
language = "English",
volume = "16",
pages = "136--158",
journal = "Violence Against Women",
issn = "1077-8012",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Inc.",
number = "2",

}

Gendered and Social Hierarchies in Problem Representation and Policy Processes : ''Domestic Violence'' in Finland and Scotland. / Hearn, Jeff; McKie, Linda.

In: Violence Against Women, Vol. 16, No. 2, 2010, p. 136-158.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Gendered and Social Hierarchies in Problem Representation and Policy Processes

T2 - ''Domestic Violence'' in Finland and Scotland

AU - Hearn, Jeff

AU - McKie, Linda

PY - 2010

Y1 - 2010

N2 - This article identifies and critiques presumptions about gender and violence that continue to frame and inform the processes of policy formation and implementation on domestic violence. It also deconstructs the agendered nature of policy as gendered, multilevel individual and collective action. Drawing on comparative illustrative material from Finland and Scotland, we discuss how national policies and discourses emphasize physical forms of violence, place the onus on the agency of women, and encourage a narrow conceptualization of violence in relationships. The two countries do this in somewhat comparable, though different ways operating within distinct national gender contexts. The complex interweaving of masculinities, violence, and cultures, although recognized in many debates, is seemingly marginalized from dominant discourses, policy, and legal processes. Despite growth in critical studies on men, there is little attempt made to problematize the gendered nature of violence. Rather, policy and service outcomes reflect processes through which individualized and masculine discourses frame ideas, discourses, and policy work. Women experiencing violence are constructed as victims and potential survivors of violence, although the social and gendered hierarchies evident in policies and services result in longer-term inequities and suffering for women and their dependents.

AB - This article identifies and critiques presumptions about gender and violence that continue to frame and inform the processes of policy formation and implementation on domestic violence. It also deconstructs the agendered nature of policy as gendered, multilevel individual and collective action. Drawing on comparative illustrative material from Finland and Scotland, we discuss how national policies and discourses emphasize physical forms of violence, place the onus on the agency of women, and encourage a narrow conceptualization of violence in relationships. The two countries do this in somewhat comparable, though different ways operating within distinct national gender contexts. The complex interweaving of masculinities, violence, and cultures, although recognized in many debates, is seemingly marginalized from dominant discourses, policy, and legal processes. Despite growth in critical studies on men, there is little attempt made to problematize the gendered nature of violence. Rather, policy and service outcomes reflect processes through which individualized and masculine discourses frame ideas, discourses, and policy work. Women experiencing violence are constructed as victims and potential survivors of violence, although the social and gendered hierarchies evident in policies and services result in longer-term inequities and suffering for women and their dependents.

KW - Domestic violence

KW - Finland

KW - Gender

KW - Policy

KW - Problem representation

KW - Scotland

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=73549087665&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://journals.sagepub.com/home/vaw

U2 - 10.1177/1077801209355185

DO - 10.1177/1077801209355185

M3 - Article

VL - 16

SP - 136

EP - 158

JO - Violence Against Women

JF - Violence Against Women

SN - 1077-8012

IS - 2

ER -