Geographical profiling in a novel context

Prioritising the search for New Zealand sex offfenders

Laura Hammond

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

8 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The present work explores the utility and value of geographical offender profiling methodologies within a novel context, considering both theoretical and practical issues relating to their application. The effectiveness of a well-known geographical profiling system, Dragnet, was tested across 101 New Zealand sex offence series, and findings compared with those derived for an equivalent sample from the UK. Average search costs (the amount of the total offence area that needed to be searched, starting from predicted offender home location, before the offender's actual home was reached) were far greater for the New Zealand sample than their UK offending counterparts. It is argued that this is because the spatial behaviour of New Zealand offenders violates many of the assumptions that Dragnet and other similar geographical profiling systems make in predicting offenders' home locations. Calibration of the system to the specific home-crime distance patterns of the New Zealand offenders did not enhance the efficacy of predictions made to a significant extent. It is consequently argued that, in their current form, geographical profiling systems are limited in their ability to account for samples displaying very different spatial characteristics to those that they were developed from and for. The implications of these findings for the general utility of geographical profiling are discussed, and ways in which systems might be developed in order to broaden their scope and applicability are suggested.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)358-371
Number of pages14
JournalPsychology, Crime and Law
Volume20
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Apr 2014

Fingerprint

New Zealand
offender
offense
Spatial Behavior
Aptitude
Sex Offenses
Crime
Calibration
Costs and Cost Analysis
methodology
ability
costs
Values

Cite this

@article{c5892139dc9d428e80c1640c0573e531,
title = "Geographical profiling in a novel context: Prioritising the search for New Zealand sex offfenders",
abstract = "The present work explores the utility and value of geographical offender profiling methodologies within a novel context, considering both theoretical and practical issues relating to their application. The effectiveness of a well-known geographical profiling system, Dragnet, was tested across 101 New Zealand sex offence series, and findings compared with those derived for an equivalent sample from the UK. Average search costs (the amount of the total offence area that needed to be searched, starting from predicted offender home location, before the offender's actual home was reached) were far greater for the New Zealand sample than their UK offending counterparts. It is argued that this is because the spatial behaviour of New Zealand offenders violates many of the assumptions that Dragnet and other similar geographical profiling systems make in predicting offenders' home locations. Calibration of the system to the specific home-crime distance patterns of the New Zealand offenders did not enhance the efficacy of predictions made to a significant extent. It is consequently argued that, in their current form, geographical profiling systems are limited in their ability to account for samples displaying very different spatial characteristics to those that they were developed from and for. The implications of these findings for the general utility of geographical profiling are discussed, and ways in which systems might be developed in order to broaden their scope and applicability are suggested.",
keywords = "Dragnet, geographical profiling, journey-to-crime, sex offences",
author = "Laura Hammond",
year = "2014",
month = "4",
doi = "10.1080/1068316X.2013.793331",
language = "English",
volume = "20",
pages = "358--371",
journal = "Psychology, Crime and Law",
issn = "1068-316X",
publisher = "Routledge",
number = "4",

}

Geographical profiling in a novel context : Prioritising the search for New Zealand sex offfenders. / Hammond, Laura.

In: Psychology, Crime and Law, Vol. 20, No. 4, 04.2014, p. 358-371.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Geographical profiling in a novel context

T2 - Prioritising the search for New Zealand sex offfenders

AU - Hammond, Laura

PY - 2014/4

Y1 - 2014/4

N2 - The present work explores the utility and value of geographical offender profiling methodologies within a novel context, considering both theoretical and practical issues relating to their application. The effectiveness of a well-known geographical profiling system, Dragnet, was tested across 101 New Zealand sex offence series, and findings compared with those derived for an equivalent sample from the UK. Average search costs (the amount of the total offence area that needed to be searched, starting from predicted offender home location, before the offender's actual home was reached) were far greater for the New Zealand sample than their UK offending counterparts. It is argued that this is because the spatial behaviour of New Zealand offenders violates many of the assumptions that Dragnet and other similar geographical profiling systems make in predicting offenders' home locations. Calibration of the system to the specific home-crime distance patterns of the New Zealand offenders did not enhance the efficacy of predictions made to a significant extent. It is consequently argued that, in their current form, geographical profiling systems are limited in their ability to account for samples displaying very different spatial characteristics to those that they were developed from and for. The implications of these findings for the general utility of geographical profiling are discussed, and ways in which systems might be developed in order to broaden their scope and applicability are suggested.

AB - The present work explores the utility and value of geographical offender profiling methodologies within a novel context, considering both theoretical and practical issues relating to their application. The effectiveness of a well-known geographical profiling system, Dragnet, was tested across 101 New Zealand sex offence series, and findings compared with those derived for an equivalent sample from the UK. Average search costs (the amount of the total offence area that needed to be searched, starting from predicted offender home location, before the offender's actual home was reached) were far greater for the New Zealand sample than their UK offending counterparts. It is argued that this is because the spatial behaviour of New Zealand offenders violates many of the assumptions that Dragnet and other similar geographical profiling systems make in predicting offenders' home locations. Calibration of the system to the specific home-crime distance patterns of the New Zealand offenders did not enhance the efficacy of predictions made to a significant extent. It is consequently argued that, in their current form, geographical profiling systems are limited in their ability to account for samples displaying very different spatial characteristics to those that they were developed from and for. The implications of these findings for the general utility of geographical profiling are discussed, and ways in which systems might be developed in order to broaden their scope and applicability are suggested.

KW - Dragnet

KW - geographical profiling

KW - journey-to-crime

KW - sex offences

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84897625308&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/1068316X.2013.793331

DO - 10.1080/1068316X.2013.793331

M3 - Article

VL - 20

SP - 358

EP - 371

JO - Psychology, Crime and Law

JF - Psychology, Crime and Law

SN - 1068-316X

IS - 4

ER -