Henry VIII's progress through Yorkshire in 1541 and its implications for northern identities

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Henry's visit to the North in 1541 has been seen as, alternatively, a powerful response to the ongoing threat to order in the years after the Pilgrimage of Grace or a move in diplomatic relationships with Scotland and France. This paper suggests the level of immediate threat of disorder in the North was low and that the role of the journey in relations with Scotland was more its consequence than its cause. Rather it finds the significance of the visit in a potential renegotiation of the position of the North within the wider realm, a question opened by political and constitutional changes since 1530, a negotiation which the King himself overthrew. Instead of accommodation, Henry sought to emphasise the extent of his defeat of the Pilgrims and the Percy interest, and to humiliate utterly all but the most clearly loyal elements, especially in York itself. Yet the memory of his triumph, if triumph it was, was poisoned for Henry by his failure to meet James of Scotland and by the collapse of his marriage to Catherine Howard; and it passed remarkably quickly from the collective memory of the North, overlain by a developing sense of relations with the Tudors, as with their predecessors, as supportive of a distinctive northern identity.

LanguageEnglish
JournalNorthern History
Volume46
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Sep 2009

Fingerprint

Henry VIII
Yorkshire
Scotland
Threat
Pilgrims
France
Collective Memory
Defeat
Marriage
Journey
Accommodation
Pilgrimage
Causes

Cite this

@article{218cae5c70ea452990ab0dbd8a451b8e,
title = "Henry VIII's progress through Yorkshire in 1541 and its implications for northern identities",
abstract = "Henry's visit to the North in 1541 has been seen as, alternatively, a powerful response to the ongoing threat to order in the years after the Pilgrimage of Grace or a move in diplomatic relationships with Scotland and France. This paper suggests the level of immediate threat of disorder in the North was low and that the role of the journey in relations with Scotland was more its consequence than its cause. Rather it finds the significance of the visit in a potential renegotiation of the position of the North within the wider realm, a question opened by political and constitutional changes since 1530, a negotiation which the King himself overthrew. Instead of accommodation, Henry sought to emphasise the extent of his defeat of the Pilgrims and the Percy interest, and to humiliate utterly all but the most clearly loyal elements, especially in York itself. Yet the memory of his triumph, if triumph it was, was poisoned for Henry by his failure to meet James of Scotland and by the collapse of his marriage to Catherine Howard; and it passed remarkably quickly from the collective memory of the North, overlain by a developing sense of relations with the Tudors, as with their predecessors, as supportive of a distinctive northern identity.",
keywords = "Ceremonial, Henry VIII, Hull, North of England, Pilgrimage of Grace, Scotland, York",
author = "Tim Thornton",
year = "2009",
month = "9",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1179/174587009X452323",
language = "English",
volume = "46",
journal = "Northern History",
issn = "0078-172X",
publisher = "Maney Publishing",
number = "2",

}

Henry VIII's progress through Yorkshire in 1541 and its implications for northern identities. / Thornton, Tim.

In: Northern History, Vol. 46, No. 2, 01.09.2009.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Henry VIII's progress through Yorkshire in 1541 and its implications for northern identities

AU - Thornton, Tim

PY - 2009/9/1

Y1 - 2009/9/1

N2 - Henry's visit to the North in 1541 has been seen as, alternatively, a powerful response to the ongoing threat to order in the years after the Pilgrimage of Grace or a move in diplomatic relationships with Scotland and France. This paper suggests the level of immediate threat of disorder in the North was low and that the role of the journey in relations with Scotland was more its consequence than its cause. Rather it finds the significance of the visit in a potential renegotiation of the position of the North within the wider realm, a question opened by political and constitutional changes since 1530, a negotiation which the King himself overthrew. Instead of accommodation, Henry sought to emphasise the extent of his defeat of the Pilgrims and the Percy interest, and to humiliate utterly all but the most clearly loyal elements, especially in York itself. Yet the memory of his triumph, if triumph it was, was poisoned for Henry by his failure to meet James of Scotland and by the collapse of his marriage to Catherine Howard; and it passed remarkably quickly from the collective memory of the North, overlain by a developing sense of relations with the Tudors, as with their predecessors, as supportive of a distinctive northern identity.

AB - Henry's visit to the North in 1541 has been seen as, alternatively, a powerful response to the ongoing threat to order in the years after the Pilgrimage of Grace or a move in diplomatic relationships with Scotland and France. This paper suggests the level of immediate threat of disorder in the North was low and that the role of the journey in relations with Scotland was more its consequence than its cause. Rather it finds the significance of the visit in a potential renegotiation of the position of the North within the wider realm, a question opened by political and constitutional changes since 1530, a negotiation which the King himself overthrew. Instead of accommodation, Henry sought to emphasise the extent of his defeat of the Pilgrims and the Percy interest, and to humiliate utterly all but the most clearly loyal elements, especially in York itself. Yet the memory of his triumph, if triumph it was, was poisoned for Henry by his failure to meet James of Scotland and by the collapse of his marriage to Catherine Howard; and it passed remarkably quickly from the collective memory of the North, overlain by a developing sense of relations with the Tudors, as with their predecessors, as supportive of a distinctive northern identity.

KW - Ceremonial

KW - Henry VIII

KW - Hull

KW - North of England

KW - Pilgrimage of Grace

KW - Scotland

KW - York

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=74749104611&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1179/174587009X452323

DO - 10.1179/174587009X452323

M3 - Article

VL - 46

JO - Northern History

T2 - Northern History

JF - Northern History

SN - 0078-172X

IS - 2

ER -