Influence of distortion on guitar chord structures: Acoustic effects and perceptual correlates

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Abstract

Since the exploration of distortion as a means of expression in the 1950s, the electric guitar has become a primary instrument in popular music, especially in rock and metal music. Despite this development, there is little musicological research on the use and perception of distorted guitar chords. This work aimed at exploring the influence of distortion on guitar chord structures, at identifying acoustic features potentially causing dissonance and at finding explanations for the common use of simple chords in rock and metal music genres. The research followed a two-step experimental design. Based on Terhardt’s (1984) and Aures’ (1985) two-component framework of musical consonance, the main study statistically evaluated acoustic characteristics of 270 electric guitar chords produced with different sound settings, instruments and amplifiers. In a second step, data of a listening test with 171 participants were triangulated with the acoustic results for considering the perceptual perspective as well. The findings largely confirmed distortion to decrease sensory pleasantness especially for complex guitar chords. The parameters of sensory consonance strongly correlated with the listeners’ perceptions. Surprisingly, roughness as the key criterion for dissonance in Helmholtz’ tradition was found the least reliable variable for explaining decreased sonority of distorted guitar sounds.
LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationMusikpsychologie
Subtitle of host publicationAkustik und musikalische Hörwahrnehmung
EditorsWolfgang Auhagen, Claudia Bullerjahn, Christoph Louven
PublisherHogrefe Verlag GmbH and Co. KG
Pages26-47
Number of pages22
Volume27
Edition1
ISBN (Print)9783801728571
Publication statusPublished - Dec 2017

Publication series

NameYearbook of the German Society for Music Psychology
PublisherHogrefe
Volume27

Fingerprint

music
acoustics
metal
rock
experimental design
roughness
effect
sound

Cite this

Herbst, J-P. (2017). Influence of distortion on guitar chord structures: Acoustic effects and perceptual correlates. In W. Auhagen, C. Bullerjahn, & C. Louven (Eds.), Musikpsychologie: Akustik und musikalische Hörwahrnehmung (1 ed., Vol. 27, pp. 26-47). (Yearbook of the German Society for Music Psychology; Vol. 27). Hogrefe Verlag GmbH and Co. KG.
Herbst, Jan-Peter. / Influence of distortion on guitar chord structures : Acoustic effects and perceptual correlates. Musikpsychologie: Akustik und musikalische Hörwahrnehmung. editor / Wolfgang Auhagen ; Claudia Bullerjahn ; Christoph Louven. Vol. 27 1. ed. Hogrefe Verlag GmbH and Co. KG, 2017. pp. 26-47 (Yearbook of the German Society for Music Psychology).
@inbook{43a3ab3108d743258b8a3b94b89d56f3,
title = "Influence of distortion on guitar chord structures: Acoustic effects and perceptual correlates",
abstract = "Since the exploration of distortion as a means of expression in the 1950s, the electric guitar has become a primary instrument in popular music, especially in rock and metal music. Despite this development, there is little musicological research on the use and perception of distorted guitar chords. This work aimed at exploring the influence of distortion on guitar chord structures, at identifying acoustic features potentially causing dissonance and at finding explanations for the common use of simple chords in rock and metal music genres. The research followed a two-step experimental design. Based on Terhardt’s (1984) and Aures’ (1985) two-component framework of musical consonance, the main study statistically evaluated acoustic characteristics of 270 electric guitar chords produced with different sound settings, instruments and amplifiers. In a second step, data of a listening test with 171 participants were triangulated with the acoustic results for considering the perceptual perspective as well. The findings largely confirmed distortion to decrease sensory pleasantness especially for complex guitar chords. The parameters of sensory consonance strongly correlated with the listeners’ perceptions. Surprisingly, roughness as the key criterion for dissonance in Helmholtz’ tradition was found the least reliable variable for explaining decreased sonority of distorted guitar sounds.",
author = "Jan-Peter Herbst",
year = "2017",
month = "12",
language = "English",
isbn = "9783801728571",
volume = "27",
series = "Yearbook of the German Society for Music Psychology",
publisher = "Hogrefe Verlag GmbH and Co. KG",
pages = "26--47",
editor = "Wolfgang Auhagen and Claudia Bullerjahn and Christoph Louven",
booktitle = "Musikpsychologie",
address = "Germany",
edition = "1",

}

Herbst, J-P 2017, Influence of distortion on guitar chord structures: Acoustic effects and perceptual correlates. in W Auhagen, C Bullerjahn & C Louven (eds), Musikpsychologie: Akustik und musikalische Hörwahrnehmung. 1 edn, vol. 27, Yearbook of the German Society for Music Psychology, vol. 27, Hogrefe Verlag GmbH and Co. KG, pp. 26-47.

Influence of distortion on guitar chord structures : Acoustic effects and perceptual correlates. / Herbst, Jan-Peter.

Musikpsychologie: Akustik und musikalische Hörwahrnehmung. ed. / Wolfgang Auhagen; Claudia Bullerjahn; Christoph Louven. Vol. 27 1. ed. Hogrefe Verlag GmbH and Co. KG, 2017. p. 26-47 (Yearbook of the German Society for Music Psychology; Vol. 27).

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - Influence of distortion on guitar chord structures

T2 - Acoustic effects and perceptual correlates

AU - Herbst, Jan-Peter

PY - 2017/12

Y1 - 2017/12

N2 - Since the exploration of distortion as a means of expression in the 1950s, the electric guitar has become a primary instrument in popular music, especially in rock and metal music. Despite this development, there is little musicological research on the use and perception of distorted guitar chords. This work aimed at exploring the influence of distortion on guitar chord structures, at identifying acoustic features potentially causing dissonance and at finding explanations for the common use of simple chords in rock and metal music genres. The research followed a two-step experimental design. Based on Terhardt’s (1984) and Aures’ (1985) two-component framework of musical consonance, the main study statistically evaluated acoustic characteristics of 270 electric guitar chords produced with different sound settings, instruments and amplifiers. In a second step, data of a listening test with 171 participants were triangulated with the acoustic results for considering the perceptual perspective as well. The findings largely confirmed distortion to decrease sensory pleasantness especially for complex guitar chords. The parameters of sensory consonance strongly correlated with the listeners’ perceptions. Surprisingly, roughness as the key criterion for dissonance in Helmholtz’ tradition was found the least reliable variable for explaining decreased sonority of distorted guitar sounds.

AB - Since the exploration of distortion as a means of expression in the 1950s, the electric guitar has become a primary instrument in popular music, especially in rock and metal music. Despite this development, there is little musicological research on the use and perception of distorted guitar chords. This work aimed at exploring the influence of distortion on guitar chord structures, at identifying acoustic features potentially causing dissonance and at finding explanations for the common use of simple chords in rock and metal music genres. The research followed a two-step experimental design. Based on Terhardt’s (1984) and Aures’ (1985) two-component framework of musical consonance, the main study statistically evaluated acoustic characteristics of 270 electric guitar chords produced with different sound settings, instruments and amplifiers. In a second step, data of a listening test with 171 participants were triangulated with the acoustic results for considering the perceptual perspective as well. The findings largely confirmed distortion to decrease sensory pleasantness especially for complex guitar chords. The parameters of sensory consonance strongly correlated with the listeners’ perceptions. Surprisingly, roughness as the key criterion for dissonance in Helmholtz’ tradition was found the least reliable variable for explaining decreased sonority of distorted guitar sounds.

UR - https://www.hogrefe.de/shop/musikpsychologie-akustik-und-musikalische-hoerwahrnehmung-84486.html

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9783801728571

VL - 27

T3 - Yearbook of the German Society for Music Psychology

SP - 26

EP - 47

BT - Musikpsychologie

A2 - Auhagen, Wolfgang

A2 - Bullerjahn, Claudia

A2 - Louven, Christoph

PB - Hogrefe Verlag GmbH and Co. KG

ER -

Herbst J-P. Influence of distortion on guitar chord structures: Acoustic effects and perceptual correlates. In Auhagen W, Bullerjahn C, Louven C, editors, Musikpsychologie: Akustik und musikalische Hörwahrnehmung. 1 ed. Vol. 27. Hogrefe Verlag GmbH and Co. KG. 2017. p. 26-47. (Yearbook of the German Society for Music Psychology).