Influence of sample surface height for evaluation of peak extraction algorithms in confocal microscopy

Jun-Cheng Chen, Jian Wang, Xiaojun Liu, Wenlong Lu, Hong Zhu, Xiangqian Jiang

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

15 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The axial resolution of confocal microscopy is not only dependent on optical characteristics but also on the utilized peak extraction algorithms. In previous evaluations of peak extraction algorithms, sample surface height is generally assumed to be zero, and only sampling-noise-induced peak extraction uncertainty was analyzed. Here we propose a sample surface-height-dependent (SHD) evaluation model that takes the combined considerations of sample surface height and noise for comparisons of algorithms’ performances. Monte Carlo simulations were first conducted on the centroid algorithm and several nonlinear fitting algorithms such as the parabola fitting algorithm, Gaussian fitting algorithm, and sinc 2 fitting algorithm. Subsequently, the evaluation indicators, including mean peak extraction error and mean uncertainty were suggested for the algorithms’ performance ranking. Finally, experimental verifications of the SHD model were carried out using a fiber-based chromatic confocal system. From our simulations and experiments, we demonstrate that sample surface height is a critical influencing factor in peak extraction computation in terms of both the accuracy and standard deviations. Compared to the conventional standard uncertainty evaluation model, our SHD model can provide a more comprehensive characterization of peak extraction algorithms’ performance and offer a more flexible and consistent reference for algorithm selection.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)6516-6526
Number of pages11
JournalApplied Optics
Volume57
Issue number22
Early online date30 Jul 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Aug 2018

Fingerprint

Confocal microscopy
microscopy
evaluation
parabolas
ranking
centroids
standard deviation
simulation
sampling
Sampling
deviation

Cite this

Chen, Jun-Cheng ; Wang, Jian ; Liu, Xiaojun ; Lu, Wenlong ; Zhu, Hong ; Jiang, Xiangqian. / Influence of sample surface height for evaluation of peak extraction algorithms in confocal microscopy. In: Applied Optics. 2018 ; Vol. 57, No. 22. pp. 6516-6526.
@article{5016aa342b39421191647a02c4eaeeda,
title = "Influence of sample surface height for evaluation of peak extraction algorithms in confocal microscopy",
abstract = "The axial resolution of confocal microscopy is not only dependent on optical characteristics but also on the utilized peak extraction algorithms. In previous evaluations of peak extraction algorithms, sample surface height is generally assumed to be zero, and only sampling-noise-induced peak extraction uncertainty was analyzed. Here we propose a sample surface-height-dependent (SHD) evaluation model that takes the combined considerations of sample surface height and noise for comparisons of algorithms’ performances. Monte Carlo simulations were first conducted on the centroid algorithm and several nonlinear fitting algorithms such as the parabola fitting algorithm, Gaussian fitting algorithm, and sinc 2 fitting algorithm. Subsequently, the evaluation indicators, including mean peak extraction error and mean uncertainty were suggested for the algorithms’ performance ranking. Finally, experimental verifications of the SHD model were carried out using a fiber-based chromatic confocal system. From our simulations and experiments, we demonstrate that sample surface height is a critical influencing factor in peak extraction computation in terms of both the accuracy and standard deviations. Compared to the conventional standard uncertainty evaluation model, our SHD model can provide a more comprehensive characterization of peak extraction algorithms’ performance and offer a more flexible and consistent reference for algorithm selection.",
author = "Jun-Cheng Chen and Jian Wang and Xiaojun Liu and Wenlong Lu and Hong Zhu and Xiangqian Jiang",
year = "2018",
month = "8",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1364/AO.57.006516",
language = "English",
volume = "57",
pages = "6516--6526",
journal = "Applied Optics",
issn = "1559-128X",
publisher = "The Optical Society",
number = "22",

}

Influence of sample surface height for evaluation of peak extraction algorithms in confocal microscopy. / Chen, Jun-Cheng; Wang, Jian; Liu, Xiaojun; Lu, Wenlong; Zhu, Hong; Jiang, Xiangqian.

In: Applied Optics, Vol. 57, No. 22, 01.08.2018, p. 6516-6526.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Influence of sample surface height for evaluation of peak extraction algorithms in confocal microscopy

AU - Chen, Jun-Cheng

AU - Wang, Jian

AU - Liu, Xiaojun

AU - Lu, Wenlong

AU - Zhu, Hong

AU - Jiang, Xiangqian

PY - 2018/8/1

Y1 - 2018/8/1

N2 - The axial resolution of confocal microscopy is not only dependent on optical characteristics but also on the utilized peak extraction algorithms. In previous evaluations of peak extraction algorithms, sample surface height is generally assumed to be zero, and only sampling-noise-induced peak extraction uncertainty was analyzed. Here we propose a sample surface-height-dependent (SHD) evaluation model that takes the combined considerations of sample surface height and noise for comparisons of algorithms’ performances. Monte Carlo simulations were first conducted on the centroid algorithm and several nonlinear fitting algorithms such as the parabola fitting algorithm, Gaussian fitting algorithm, and sinc 2 fitting algorithm. Subsequently, the evaluation indicators, including mean peak extraction error and mean uncertainty were suggested for the algorithms’ performance ranking. Finally, experimental verifications of the SHD model were carried out using a fiber-based chromatic confocal system. From our simulations and experiments, we demonstrate that sample surface height is a critical influencing factor in peak extraction computation in terms of both the accuracy and standard deviations. Compared to the conventional standard uncertainty evaluation model, our SHD model can provide a more comprehensive characterization of peak extraction algorithms’ performance and offer a more flexible and consistent reference for algorithm selection.

AB - The axial resolution of confocal microscopy is not only dependent on optical characteristics but also on the utilized peak extraction algorithms. In previous evaluations of peak extraction algorithms, sample surface height is generally assumed to be zero, and only sampling-noise-induced peak extraction uncertainty was analyzed. Here we propose a sample surface-height-dependent (SHD) evaluation model that takes the combined considerations of sample surface height and noise for comparisons of algorithms’ performances. Monte Carlo simulations were first conducted on the centroid algorithm and several nonlinear fitting algorithms such as the parabola fitting algorithm, Gaussian fitting algorithm, and sinc 2 fitting algorithm. Subsequently, the evaluation indicators, including mean peak extraction error and mean uncertainty were suggested for the algorithms’ performance ranking. Finally, experimental verifications of the SHD model were carried out using a fiber-based chromatic confocal system. From our simulations and experiments, we demonstrate that sample surface height is a critical influencing factor in peak extraction computation in terms of both the accuracy and standard deviations. Compared to the conventional standard uncertainty evaluation model, our SHD model can provide a more comprehensive characterization of peak extraction algorithms’ performance and offer a more flexible and consistent reference for algorithm selection.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85051321623&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1364/AO.57.006516

DO - 10.1364/AO.57.006516

M3 - Article

VL - 57

SP - 6516

EP - 6526

JO - Applied Optics

JF - Applied Optics

SN - 1559-128X

IS - 22

ER -