Irreconcilable Differences?: The Road Traffic Act and the European Motor Vehicle Insurance Directives

James Marson, Katy Ferris, Alex Nicholson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The UK has a chequered past in relation to its compliance with EU law. In some instances, it has gone beyond the minimum requirements imposed by its EU parent in providing protection for individuals (see for instance the UK’s implementation of Art. 9 of the Motor Vehicle Insurance Directive 2009/103/EC). Regrettably, however, there is a greater number of examples where the UK has failed in its transposition obligations. One area where a significant disconnect exists between national and EU law is third party motor vehicle insurance. This is perhaps justifiable in some instances given the evolution of the domestic and EU laws, their original incarnation compared with modern requirements, and the effects of judicial interpretation and the creativity of the Court of Justice of the European Union. However, other inconsistencies are less easy to accept. There are an increasing number of errors in interpretation, historic and contemporary, which necessitate a comprehensive review of the national law, a policy review of the state’s abrogation of its responsibilities to the victims of uninsured and untraced drivers, and corrective action to prevent liability being imposed on the UK.
LanguageEnglish
Number of pages22
JournalJournal of Business Law
Publication statusPublished - 2017

Fingerprint

irreconcilable differences
European Law
road traffic
insurance
motor vehicle
act
court of justice
interpretation
European Community
liability
creativity
obligation
parents
EU
driver
responsibility
Law

Cite this

@article{b4ff783183ab4d8e953d49c9ec6e0186,
title = "Irreconcilable Differences?: The Road Traffic Act and the European Motor Vehicle Insurance Directives",
abstract = "The UK has a chequered past in relation to its compliance with EU law. In some instances, it has gone beyond the minimum requirements imposed by its EU parent in providing protection for individuals (see for instance the UK’s implementation of Art. 9 of the Motor Vehicle Insurance Directive 2009/103/EC). Regrettably, however, there is a greater number of examples where the UK has failed in its transposition obligations. One area where a significant disconnect exists between national and EU law is third party motor vehicle insurance. This is perhaps justifiable in some instances given the evolution of the domestic and EU laws, their original incarnation compared with modern requirements, and the effects of judicial interpretation and the creativity of the Court of Justice of the European Union. However, other inconsistencies are less easy to accept. There are an increasing number of errors in interpretation, historic and contemporary, which necessitate a comprehensive review of the national law, a policy review of the state’s abrogation of its responsibilities to the victims of uninsured and untraced drivers, and corrective action to prevent liability being imposed on the UK.",
keywords = "Vehicle Insurance, European Union Law",
author = "James Marson and Katy Ferris and Alex Nicholson",
year = "2017",
language = "English",
journal = "Journal of Business Law",
issn = "0021-9460",
publisher = "Sweet and Maxwell Ltd.",

}

Irreconcilable Differences? The Road Traffic Act and the European Motor Vehicle Insurance Directives. / Marson, James; Ferris, Katy; Nicholson, Alex.

In: Journal of Business Law, 2017.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Irreconcilable Differences?

T2 - Journal of Business Law

AU - Marson, James

AU - Ferris, Katy

AU - Nicholson, Alex

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - The UK has a chequered past in relation to its compliance with EU law. In some instances, it has gone beyond the minimum requirements imposed by its EU parent in providing protection for individuals (see for instance the UK’s implementation of Art. 9 of the Motor Vehicle Insurance Directive 2009/103/EC). Regrettably, however, there is a greater number of examples where the UK has failed in its transposition obligations. One area where a significant disconnect exists between national and EU law is third party motor vehicle insurance. This is perhaps justifiable in some instances given the evolution of the domestic and EU laws, their original incarnation compared with modern requirements, and the effects of judicial interpretation and the creativity of the Court of Justice of the European Union. However, other inconsistencies are less easy to accept. There are an increasing number of errors in interpretation, historic and contemporary, which necessitate a comprehensive review of the national law, a policy review of the state’s abrogation of its responsibilities to the victims of uninsured and untraced drivers, and corrective action to prevent liability being imposed on the UK.

AB - The UK has a chequered past in relation to its compliance with EU law. In some instances, it has gone beyond the minimum requirements imposed by its EU parent in providing protection for individuals (see for instance the UK’s implementation of Art. 9 of the Motor Vehicle Insurance Directive 2009/103/EC). Regrettably, however, there is a greater number of examples where the UK has failed in its transposition obligations. One area where a significant disconnect exists between national and EU law is third party motor vehicle insurance. This is perhaps justifiable in some instances given the evolution of the domestic and EU laws, their original incarnation compared with modern requirements, and the effects of judicial interpretation and the creativity of the Court of Justice of the European Union. However, other inconsistencies are less easy to accept. There are an increasing number of errors in interpretation, historic and contemporary, which necessitate a comprehensive review of the national law, a policy review of the state’s abrogation of its responsibilities to the victims of uninsured and untraced drivers, and corrective action to prevent liability being imposed on the UK.

KW - Vehicle Insurance

KW - European Union Law

UR - http://www.sweetandmaxwell.co.uk/Catalogue/ProductDetails.aspx?recordid=476

M3 - Article

JO - Journal of Business Law

JF - Journal of Business Law

SN - 0021-9460

ER -