Place of technology management as a key process area within UK construction process improvement

A critical analysis

Kaushal Keraminiyage, Dilanthi Amaratunga, Richard Haigh

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Abstract

Process improvement has been identified as an important strategy to address the current unpredictability and under-achievements of the UK construction industry. Within the technological view of process improvement, information technology (IT) has been identified as a key enabler. Various studies about the information technology in construction have revealed that construction show a slow IT adoptability and IT has failed to convince the stakeholders of the construction industry. Within some of these researches, it has been argued that immature processes within the construction industry are responsible for this unsatisfactory level of performance of IT. On the other hand, it has also been argued that, Information Technology is a primary stimulant of process improvement, thus process maturity can be driven by the IT push. Leading to a dilemma, this indicates that new information technological innovations could use by immature organisations within their process improvement strategies. This dilemma triggered the necessity to evaluate the place of the Technology Change Management within the construction context. Thus, a literature survey was conducted to identify the construction process improvement initiatives and its relationship with the IT usage in construction with a special emphasis on the SPICE approach, which has provided the basis for this critical analysis. The SPICE is a five levelled framework based on the popular Software Capability Maturity Model (CMM), and presents an assessment tool for the maturity of construction process. However, within the CMM the Technology Change Management has been considered as a key process area within the fifth maturity level, indicating that this is a concern of matured organisations. However, the IT usage within construction shows that the immature construction organisations have successfully adopted IT in an ad-hoc manner with the aim of achieving short term benefits. On the other hand construction literature have criticised this ad-hoc IT usage and linked that to the relative slow IT adoptability in construction. This in effect challenges the allocation of a fixed place for Technology Change Management as a Key Process Area with the construction process improvement, from the organisation maturity point of view.

Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationQueensland University of Technology Research Week International Conference, QUT Research Week 2005 - Conference Proceedings
EditorsAnthony Charles Sidwell
PublisherQueensland University of Technology
ISBN (Print)1741071011, 9781741071016
Publication statusPublished - 1 Dec 2005
Externally publishedYes
EventQueensland University of Technology Research Week International Conference - Brisbane, Australia
Duration: 4 Jul 20058 Jul 2005

Conference

ConferenceQueensland University of Technology Research Week International Conference
Abbreviated titleQUT Research Week 2005
CountryAustralia
CityBrisbane
Period4/07/058/07/05

Fingerprint

Information technology
Construction industry
SPICE
Process improvement
Management of technology
Innovation

Cite this

Keraminiyage, K., Amaratunga, D., & Haigh, R. (2005). Place of technology management as a key process area within UK construction process improvement: A critical analysis. In A. C. Sidwell (Ed.), Queensland University of Technology Research Week International Conference, QUT Research Week 2005 - Conference Proceedings Queensland University of Technology.
Keraminiyage, Kaushal ; Amaratunga, Dilanthi ; Haigh, Richard. / Place of technology management as a key process area within UK construction process improvement : A critical analysis. Queensland University of Technology Research Week International Conference, QUT Research Week 2005 - Conference Proceedings. editor / Anthony Charles Sidwell. Queensland University of Technology, 2005.
@inproceedings{d6dc6125481f49f8bfabdf9defdc05ed,
title = "Place of technology management as a key process area within UK construction process improvement: A critical analysis",
abstract = "Process improvement has been identified as an important strategy to address the current unpredictability and under-achievements of the UK construction industry. Within the technological view of process improvement, information technology (IT) has been identified as a key enabler. Various studies about the information technology in construction have revealed that construction show a slow IT adoptability and IT has failed to convince the stakeholders of the construction industry. Within some of these researches, it has been argued that immature processes within the construction industry are responsible for this unsatisfactory level of performance of IT. On the other hand, it has also been argued that, Information Technology is a primary stimulant of process improvement, thus process maturity can be driven by the IT push. Leading to a dilemma, this indicates that new information technological innovations could use by immature organisations within their process improvement strategies. This dilemma triggered the necessity to evaluate the place of the Technology Change Management within the construction context. Thus, a literature survey was conducted to identify the construction process improvement initiatives and its relationship with the IT usage in construction with a special emphasis on the SPICE approach, which has provided the basis for this critical analysis. The SPICE is a five levelled framework based on the popular Software Capability Maturity Model (CMM), and presents an assessment tool for the maturity of construction process. However, within the CMM the Technology Change Management has been considered as a key process area within the fifth maturity level, indicating that this is a concern of matured organisations. However, the IT usage within construction shows that the immature construction organisations have successfully adopted IT in an ad-hoc manner with the aim of achieving short term benefits. On the other hand construction literature have criticised this ad-hoc IT usage and linked that to the relative slow IT adoptability in construction. This in effect challenges the allocation of a fixed place for Technology Change Management as a Key Process Area with the construction process improvement, from the organisation maturity point of view.",
keywords = "Construction IT, Construction process improvement, IT maturity, Process maturity",
author = "Kaushal Keraminiyage and Dilanthi Amaratunga and Richard Haigh",
year = "2005",
month = "12",
day = "1",
language = "English",
isbn = "1741071011",
editor = "Sidwell, {Anthony Charles}",
booktitle = "Queensland University of Technology Research Week International Conference, QUT Research Week 2005 - Conference Proceedings",
publisher = "Queensland University of Technology",
address = "Australia",

}

Keraminiyage, K, Amaratunga, D & Haigh, R 2005, Place of technology management as a key process area within UK construction process improvement: A critical analysis. in AC Sidwell (ed.), Queensland University of Technology Research Week International Conference, QUT Research Week 2005 - Conference Proceedings. Queensland University of Technology, Queensland University of Technology Research Week International Conference, Brisbane, Australia, 4/07/05.

Place of technology management as a key process area within UK construction process improvement : A critical analysis. / Keraminiyage, Kaushal; Amaratunga, Dilanthi; Haigh, Richard.

Queensland University of Technology Research Week International Conference, QUT Research Week 2005 - Conference Proceedings. ed. / Anthony Charles Sidwell. Queensland University of Technology, 2005.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

TY - GEN

T1 - Place of technology management as a key process area within UK construction process improvement

T2 - A critical analysis

AU - Keraminiyage, Kaushal

AU - Amaratunga, Dilanthi

AU - Haigh, Richard

PY - 2005/12/1

Y1 - 2005/12/1

N2 - Process improvement has been identified as an important strategy to address the current unpredictability and under-achievements of the UK construction industry. Within the technological view of process improvement, information technology (IT) has been identified as a key enabler. Various studies about the information technology in construction have revealed that construction show a slow IT adoptability and IT has failed to convince the stakeholders of the construction industry. Within some of these researches, it has been argued that immature processes within the construction industry are responsible for this unsatisfactory level of performance of IT. On the other hand, it has also been argued that, Information Technology is a primary stimulant of process improvement, thus process maturity can be driven by the IT push. Leading to a dilemma, this indicates that new information technological innovations could use by immature organisations within their process improvement strategies. This dilemma triggered the necessity to evaluate the place of the Technology Change Management within the construction context. Thus, a literature survey was conducted to identify the construction process improvement initiatives and its relationship with the IT usage in construction with a special emphasis on the SPICE approach, which has provided the basis for this critical analysis. The SPICE is a five levelled framework based on the popular Software Capability Maturity Model (CMM), and presents an assessment tool for the maturity of construction process. However, within the CMM the Technology Change Management has been considered as a key process area within the fifth maturity level, indicating that this is a concern of matured organisations. However, the IT usage within construction shows that the immature construction organisations have successfully adopted IT in an ad-hoc manner with the aim of achieving short term benefits. On the other hand construction literature have criticised this ad-hoc IT usage and linked that to the relative slow IT adoptability in construction. This in effect challenges the allocation of a fixed place for Technology Change Management as a Key Process Area with the construction process improvement, from the organisation maturity point of view.

AB - Process improvement has been identified as an important strategy to address the current unpredictability and under-achievements of the UK construction industry. Within the technological view of process improvement, information technology (IT) has been identified as a key enabler. Various studies about the information technology in construction have revealed that construction show a slow IT adoptability and IT has failed to convince the stakeholders of the construction industry. Within some of these researches, it has been argued that immature processes within the construction industry are responsible for this unsatisfactory level of performance of IT. On the other hand, it has also been argued that, Information Technology is a primary stimulant of process improvement, thus process maturity can be driven by the IT push. Leading to a dilemma, this indicates that new information technological innovations could use by immature organisations within their process improvement strategies. This dilemma triggered the necessity to evaluate the place of the Technology Change Management within the construction context. Thus, a literature survey was conducted to identify the construction process improvement initiatives and its relationship with the IT usage in construction with a special emphasis on the SPICE approach, which has provided the basis for this critical analysis. The SPICE is a five levelled framework based on the popular Software Capability Maturity Model (CMM), and presents an assessment tool for the maturity of construction process. However, within the CMM the Technology Change Management has been considered as a key process area within the fifth maturity level, indicating that this is a concern of matured organisations. However, the IT usage within construction shows that the immature construction organisations have successfully adopted IT in an ad-hoc manner with the aim of achieving short term benefits. On the other hand construction literature have criticised this ad-hoc IT usage and linked that to the relative slow IT adoptability in construction. This in effect challenges the allocation of a fixed place for Technology Change Management as a Key Process Area with the construction process improvement, from the organisation maturity point of view.

KW - Construction IT

KW - Construction process improvement

KW - IT maturity

KW - Process maturity

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84859077001&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Conference contribution

SN - 1741071011

SN - 9781741071016

BT - Queensland University of Technology Research Week International Conference, QUT Research Week 2005 - Conference Proceedings

A2 - Sidwell, Anthony Charles

PB - Queensland University of Technology

ER -

Keraminiyage K, Amaratunga D, Haigh R. Place of technology management as a key process area within UK construction process improvement: A critical analysis. In Sidwell AC, editor, Queensland University of Technology Research Week International Conference, QUT Research Week 2005 - Conference Proceedings. Queensland University of Technology. 2005