Quantification of solvent effects on molecular recognition in polyhedral coordination cage hosts

Martina Whitehead, Simon Turega, Andrew Stephenson, Christopher A. Hunter, Michael D. Ward

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

49 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

A water-soluble cubic coordination cage (Hw) has been prepared, which is isostructural with a previously reported organic-soluble cage (H) apart from the hydroxy groups on the external surface which render it water-soluble. These two cages act as hosts for small organic molecules which bind via a combination of (i) hydrogen-bonding interactions with specific sites on the internal surface of the cages; (ii) non-polar interactions such as aromatic and van der Waals interactions between aromatic rings in the guest and the cage internal surface; and (iii) solvophobic interactions. By comparing ΔG° values for guest binding in water (using Hw) and MeCN (using H), and using pairs of related guests that differ in the presence or absence of an aromatic ring substituent, it is possible to construct thermodynamic cycles that allow quantification of the solvophobic contribution to binding. Specifically, this is the difference between the solvophobic contributions to ΔG° in water and MeCN associated with desolvation of both guest and the internal surface of the cage when complexation occurs. A highly consistent value of ca. −10 kJ mol−1 is determined for this solvophobic contribution to ΔG° associated with the aromatic ring in water compared to MeCN, which correlates very well with what would be expected based on the free energy changes associated with transfer of toluene from MeCN to water. Thus, all three contributions to guest binding listed above can be separately quantified. The ability to prepare related pairs of guests with the presence or absence of a wide range of substituents provides a potentially general way to quantify the solvophobic contributions to guest binding of these substituents.

LanguageEnglish
Pages2744-2751
Number of pages8
JournalChemical Science
Volume4
Issue number7
Early online date10 Apr 2013
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 4 Jun 2013
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Molecular recognition
Water
Toluene
Complexation
Free energy
Hydrogen bonds
Thermodynamics
Molecules

Cite this

Whitehead, Martina ; Turega, Simon ; Stephenson, Andrew ; Hunter, Christopher A. ; Ward, Michael D. / Quantification of solvent effects on molecular recognition in polyhedral coordination cage hosts. In: Chemical Science. 2013 ; Vol. 4, No. 7. pp. 2744-2751.
@article{ec0b74f0ecd149a3a6df060c7309484f,
title = "Quantification of solvent effects on molecular recognition in polyhedral coordination cage hosts",
abstract = "A water-soluble cubic coordination cage (Hw) has been prepared, which is isostructural with a previously reported organic-soluble cage (H) apart from the hydroxy groups on the external surface which render it water-soluble. These two cages act as hosts for small organic molecules which bind via a combination of (i) hydrogen-bonding interactions with specific sites on the internal surface of the cages; (ii) non-polar interactions such as aromatic and van der Waals interactions between aromatic rings in the guest and the cage internal surface; and (iii) solvophobic interactions. By comparing ΔG° values for guest binding in water (using Hw) and MeCN (using H), and using pairs of related guests that differ in the presence or absence of an aromatic ring substituent, it is possible to construct thermodynamic cycles that allow quantification of the solvophobic contribution to binding. Specifically, this is the difference between the solvophobic contributions to ΔG° in water and MeCN associated with desolvation of both guest and the internal surface of the cage when complexation occurs. A highly consistent value of ca. −10 kJ mol−1 is determined for this solvophobic contribution to ΔG° associated with the aromatic ring in water compared to MeCN, which correlates very well with what would be expected based on the free energy changes associated with transfer of toluene from MeCN to water. Thus, all three contributions to guest binding listed above can be separately quantified. The ability to prepare related pairs of guests with the presence or absence of a wide range of substituents provides a potentially general way to quantify the solvophobic contributions to guest binding of these substituents.",
author = "Martina Whitehead and Simon Turega and Andrew Stephenson and Hunter, {Christopher A.} and Ward, {Michael D.}",
year = "2013",
month = "6",
day = "4",
doi = "10.1039/c3sc50546d",
language = "English",
volume = "4",
pages = "2744--2751",
journal = "Chemical Science",
issn = "2041-6520",
publisher = "Royal Society of Chemistry",
number = "7",

}

Quantification of solvent effects on molecular recognition in polyhedral coordination cage hosts. / Whitehead, Martina; Turega, Simon; Stephenson, Andrew; Hunter, Christopher A.; Ward, Michael D.

In: Chemical Science, Vol. 4, No. 7, 04.06.2013, p. 2744-2751.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Quantification of solvent effects on molecular recognition in polyhedral coordination cage hosts

AU - Whitehead, Martina

AU - Turega, Simon

AU - Stephenson, Andrew

AU - Hunter, Christopher A.

AU - Ward, Michael D.

PY - 2013/6/4

Y1 - 2013/6/4

N2 - A water-soluble cubic coordination cage (Hw) has been prepared, which is isostructural with a previously reported organic-soluble cage (H) apart from the hydroxy groups on the external surface which render it water-soluble. These two cages act as hosts for small organic molecules which bind via a combination of (i) hydrogen-bonding interactions with specific sites on the internal surface of the cages; (ii) non-polar interactions such as aromatic and van der Waals interactions between aromatic rings in the guest and the cage internal surface; and (iii) solvophobic interactions. By comparing ΔG° values for guest binding in water (using Hw) and MeCN (using H), and using pairs of related guests that differ in the presence or absence of an aromatic ring substituent, it is possible to construct thermodynamic cycles that allow quantification of the solvophobic contribution to binding. Specifically, this is the difference between the solvophobic contributions to ΔG° in water and MeCN associated with desolvation of both guest and the internal surface of the cage when complexation occurs. A highly consistent value of ca. −10 kJ mol−1 is determined for this solvophobic contribution to ΔG° associated with the aromatic ring in water compared to MeCN, which correlates very well with what would be expected based on the free energy changes associated with transfer of toluene from MeCN to water. Thus, all three contributions to guest binding listed above can be separately quantified. The ability to prepare related pairs of guests with the presence or absence of a wide range of substituents provides a potentially general way to quantify the solvophobic contributions to guest binding of these substituents.

AB - A water-soluble cubic coordination cage (Hw) has been prepared, which is isostructural with a previously reported organic-soluble cage (H) apart from the hydroxy groups on the external surface which render it water-soluble. These two cages act as hosts for small organic molecules which bind via a combination of (i) hydrogen-bonding interactions with specific sites on the internal surface of the cages; (ii) non-polar interactions such as aromatic and van der Waals interactions between aromatic rings in the guest and the cage internal surface; and (iii) solvophobic interactions. By comparing ΔG° values for guest binding in water (using Hw) and MeCN (using H), and using pairs of related guests that differ in the presence or absence of an aromatic ring substituent, it is possible to construct thermodynamic cycles that allow quantification of the solvophobic contribution to binding. Specifically, this is the difference between the solvophobic contributions to ΔG° in water and MeCN associated with desolvation of both guest and the internal surface of the cage when complexation occurs. A highly consistent value of ca. −10 kJ mol−1 is determined for this solvophobic contribution to ΔG° associated with the aromatic ring in water compared to MeCN, which correlates very well with what would be expected based on the free energy changes associated with transfer of toluene from MeCN to water. Thus, all three contributions to guest binding listed above can be separately quantified. The ability to prepare related pairs of guests with the presence or absence of a wide range of substituents provides a potentially general way to quantify the solvophobic contributions to guest binding of these substituents.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84878798993&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1039/c3sc50546d

DO - 10.1039/c3sc50546d

M3 - Article

VL - 4

SP - 2744

EP - 2751

JO - Chemical Science

T2 - Chemical Science

JF - Chemical Science

SN - 2041-6520

IS - 7

ER -