Shifting identities

Social and cultural factors that shape decision-making around sustaining breastfeeding

Joyce L. Marshall, Mary Godfrey

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In the United Kingdom, women's beliefs, attitudes and behaviours around breastfeeding are shaped by myriad influences and by changing social and structural factors and cultural mores. Whilst public health discourse equates breastfeeding with 'good mothering' and health professionals emphasise 'breast as best', these normative values compete with other standards or criteria of 'good mothering' held by others within women's social networks that exert influence on them. Moreover, cultural and structural factors affecting the pattern of women's labour market participation, specifically public policy emphasis on return to paid work aligned with policies directed at reconciling work and family act as constraints on sustaining optimal breastfeeding, i.e. exclusive breastfeeding for 6 months as advised by the World Health Organization (2003). For women in this study, initiating and sustaining breastfeeding was subject to a complex process that contributed to multiple valued outcomes: nurturing thriving and healthy babies, experiencing themselves as 'competent' mothers, successfully managing shifting identities and negotiating competing pressures in the real-life context of their daily lives and relationships with 'significant others'. Even as women struggled to present and see themselves as 'good mothers', they were active agents and not just acted upon. They sought to reconcile the value they placed on breastfeeding with seeing themselves and being seen by others as 'good mothers'. Thus, they sought out situations where breastfeeding was highly valued (such as support groups), and developed strategies to counter or avoid threats to their sense of themselves as nurturing and competent mothers that was related to, but not synonymous with, sustaining breastfeeding. Midwives and health visitors in this study encouraged women to breastfeed but not in the way that this is generally portrayed in much of the current literature. Analysis of observed interactions between women who had chosen to breastfeed and midwives and health visitors suggests more of a negotiated encounter in which these health professional considered the whole situation of the woman and her struggle to be a 'good mother'.

Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationInfant Feeding Practices
Subtitle of host publicationA Cross-Cultural Perspective
EditorsPranee Liamputtong
PublisherSpringer New York
Pages95-108
Number of pages14
ISBN (Print)9781441968722
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 27 Sep 2010

Fingerprint

Social Identification
Breast Feeding
Decision Making
Mothers
Community Health Nurses
Midwifery
Return to Work
Self-Help Groups
Negotiating
Health
Public Policy
Social Support
Breast
Public Health
Pressure

Cite this

Marshall, J. L., & Godfrey, M. (2010). Shifting identities: Social and cultural factors that shape decision-making around sustaining breastfeeding. In P. Liamputtong (Ed.), Infant Feeding Practices: A Cross-Cultural Perspective (pp. 95-108). Springer New York. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4419-6873-9_6
Marshall, Joyce L. ; Godfrey, Mary. / Shifting identities : Social and cultural factors that shape decision-making around sustaining breastfeeding. Infant Feeding Practices: A Cross-Cultural Perspective. editor / Pranee Liamputtong. Springer New York, 2010. pp. 95-108
@inbook{d8dd8e71c76347168123ec7e3c6fd221,
title = "Shifting identities: Social and cultural factors that shape decision-making around sustaining breastfeeding",
abstract = "In the United Kingdom, women's beliefs, attitudes and behaviours around breastfeeding are shaped by myriad influences and by changing social and structural factors and cultural mores. Whilst public health discourse equates breastfeeding with 'good mothering' and health professionals emphasise 'breast as best', these normative values compete with other standards or criteria of 'good mothering' held by others within women's social networks that exert influence on them. Moreover, cultural and structural factors affecting the pattern of women's labour market participation, specifically public policy emphasis on return to paid work aligned with policies directed at reconciling work and family act as constraints on sustaining optimal breastfeeding, i.e. exclusive breastfeeding for 6 months as advised by the World Health Organization (2003). For women in this study, initiating and sustaining breastfeeding was subject to a complex process that contributed to multiple valued outcomes: nurturing thriving and healthy babies, experiencing themselves as 'competent' mothers, successfully managing shifting identities and negotiating competing pressures in the real-life context of their daily lives and relationships with 'significant others'. Even as women struggled to present and see themselves as 'good mothers', they were active agents and not just acted upon. They sought to reconcile the value they placed on breastfeeding with seeing themselves and being seen by others as 'good mothers'. Thus, they sought out situations where breastfeeding was highly valued (such as support groups), and developed strategies to counter or avoid threats to their sense of themselves as nurturing and competent mothers that was related to, but not synonymous with, sustaining breastfeeding. Midwives and health visitors in this study encouraged women to breastfeed but not in the way that this is generally portrayed in much of the current literature. Analysis of observed interactions between women who had chosen to breastfeed and midwives and health visitors suggests more of a negotiated encounter in which these health professional considered the whole situation of the woman and her struggle to be a 'good mother'.",
keywords = "Breastfeeding, Cultural, Decisions, England, Identity, Infant feeding, Motherhood, Social",
author = "Marshall, {Joyce L.} and Mary Godfrey",
year = "2010",
month = "9",
day = "27",
doi = "10.1007/978-1-4419-6873-9_6",
language = "English",
isbn = "9781441968722",
pages = "95--108",
editor = "Pranee Liamputtong",
booktitle = "Infant Feeding Practices",
publisher = "Springer New York",
address = "United States",

}

Marshall, JL & Godfrey, M 2010, Shifting identities: Social and cultural factors that shape decision-making around sustaining breastfeeding. in P Liamputtong (ed.), Infant Feeding Practices: A Cross-Cultural Perspective. Springer New York, pp. 95-108. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4419-6873-9_6

Shifting identities : Social and cultural factors that shape decision-making around sustaining breastfeeding. / Marshall, Joyce L.; Godfrey, Mary.

Infant Feeding Practices: A Cross-Cultural Perspective. ed. / Pranee Liamputtong. Springer New York, 2010. p. 95-108.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - Shifting identities

T2 - Social and cultural factors that shape decision-making around sustaining breastfeeding

AU - Marshall, Joyce L.

AU - Godfrey, Mary

PY - 2010/9/27

Y1 - 2010/9/27

N2 - In the United Kingdom, women's beliefs, attitudes and behaviours around breastfeeding are shaped by myriad influences and by changing social and structural factors and cultural mores. Whilst public health discourse equates breastfeeding with 'good mothering' and health professionals emphasise 'breast as best', these normative values compete with other standards or criteria of 'good mothering' held by others within women's social networks that exert influence on them. Moreover, cultural and structural factors affecting the pattern of women's labour market participation, specifically public policy emphasis on return to paid work aligned with policies directed at reconciling work and family act as constraints on sustaining optimal breastfeeding, i.e. exclusive breastfeeding for 6 months as advised by the World Health Organization (2003). For women in this study, initiating and sustaining breastfeeding was subject to a complex process that contributed to multiple valued outcomes: nurturing thriving and healthy babies, experiencing themselves as 'competent' mothers, successfully managing shifting identities and negotiating competing pressures in the real-life context of their daily lives and relationships with 'significant others'. Even as women struggled to present and see themselves as 'good mothers', they were active agents and not just acted upon. They sought to reconcile the value they placed on breastfeeding with seeing themselves and being seen by others as 'good mothers'. Thus, they sought out situations where breastfeeding was highly valued (such as support groups), and developed strategies to counter or avoid threats to their sense of themselves as nurturing and competent mothers that was related to, but not synonymous with, sustaining breastfeeding. Midwives and health visitors in this study encouraged women to breastfeed but not in the way that this is generally portrayed in much of the current literature. Analysis of observed interactions between women who had chosen to breastfeed and midwives and health visitors suggests more of a negotiated encounter in which these health professional considered the whole situation of the woman and her struggle to be a 'good mother'.

AB - In the United Kingdom, women's beliefs, attitudes and behaviours around breastfeeding are shaped by myriad influences and by changing social and structural factors and cultural mores. Whilst public health discourse equates breastfeeding with 'good mothering' and health professionals emphasise 'breast as best', these normative values compete with other standards or criteria of 'good mothering' held by others within women's social networks that exert influence on them. Moreover, cultural and structural factors affecting the pattern of women's labour market participation, specifically public policy emphasis on return to paid work aligned with policies directed at reconciling work and family act as constraints on sustaining optimal breastfeeding, i.e. exclusive breastfeeding for 6 months as advised by the World Health Organization (2003). For women in this study, initiating and sustaining breastfeeding was subject to a complex process that contributed to multiple valued outcomes: nurturing thriving and healthy babies, experiencing themselves as 'competent' mothers, successfully managing shifting identities and negotiating competing pressures in the real-life context of their daily lives and relationships with 'significant others'. Even as women struggled to present and see themselves as 'good mothers', they were active agents and not just acted upon. They sought to reconcile the value they placed on breastfeeding with seeing themselves and being seen by others as 'good mothers'. Thus, they sought out situations where breastfeeding was highly valued (such as support groups), and developed strategies to counter or avoid threats to their sense of themselves as nurturing and competent mothers that was related to, but not synonymous with, sustaining breastfeeding. Midwives and health visitors in this study encouraged women to breastfeed but not in the way that this is generally portrayed in much of the current literature. Analysis of observed interactions between women who had chosen to breastfeed and midwives and health visitors suggests more of a negotiated encounter in which these health professional considered the whole situation of the woman and her struggle to be a 'good mother'.

KW - Breastfeeding

KW - Cultural

KW - Decisions

KW - England

KW - Identity

KW - Infant feeding

KW - Motherhood

KW - Social

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84859202736&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/978-1-4419-6873-9_6

DO - 10.1007/978-1-4419-6873-9_6

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9781441968722

SP - 95

EP - 108

BT - Infant Feeding Practices

A2 - Liamputtong, Pranee

PB - Springer New York

ER -

Marshall JL, Godfrey M. Shifting identities: Social and cultural factors that shape decision-making around sustaining breastfeeding. In Liamputtong P, editor, Infant Feeding Practices: A Cross-Cultural Perspective. Springer New York. 2010. p. 95-108 https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4419-6873-9_6