Social Capital and Community Group Participation

Examining 'Bridging' and 'Bonding' in the Context of a Healthy Living Centre in the UK

Emma Kirkby-Geddes, Nigel King, Alison Bravington

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

17 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Social capital has been widely advocated as a way of understanding and building community participation in the interest of health improvement. However, the concept as proposed by Putnam, has been criticised for presenting an overly romanticised account of complex community relations. This paper presents analysis from a qualitative evaluation of a Healthy Living Centre (HLC) in the North of England, to examine the utility of the concept of social capital in this context. We found the concepts of 'bridging' and 'bonding' social capital were useful - though not without limitations - in helping to make sense of the complexities and contradictions in participants' experiences of community group participation. 'Bridging' helped provide an understanding of how the decline in shared social spaces such as local shops impacts on social relationships. 'Bonding' highlighted how community group membership can have positive and negative implications for individuals and the wider community. It was found that skilled group leadership was key to strengthening bridging capital. Politically, in the UK, community participation is seen as having an essential role in social change, for example, its centrality to the coalition government's idea of the 'Big Society'. A micro-examination of this HLC using the lens of social capital provides a valuable critical insight into community participation. It shows that this kind of initiative can be successful in building social capital, given conditions such as an appropriate setting and effective leadership. However, they cannot substitute for other kinds of investment in the physical infrastructure of a community.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)271-285
Number of pages15
JournalJournal of Community and Applied Social Psychology
Volume23
Issue number4
Early online date3 Jul 2012
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jul 2013

Fingerprint

social capital
participation
community
Group
Community-Institutional Relations
Social Change
England
Lenses
leadership
Economics
Community Participation
Social Capital
Object Attachment
social space
group membership
Health
coalition
social change
infrastructure
examination

Cite this

@article{178dd2fcf84041d4b263cf7c472438bd,
title = "Social Capital and Community Group Participation: Examining 'Bridging' and 'Bonding' in the Context of a Healthy Living Centre in the UK",
abstract = "Social capital has been widely advocated as a way of understanding and building community participation in the interest of health improvement. However, the concept as proposed by Putnam, has been criticised for presenting an overly romanticised account of complex community relations. This paper presents analysis from a qualitative evaluation of a Healthy Living Centre (HLC) in the North of England, to examine the utility of the concept of social capital in this context. We found the concepts of 'bridging' and 'bonding' social capital were useful - though not without limitations - in helping to make sense of the complexities and contradictions in participants' experiences of community group participation. 'Bridging' helped provide an understanding of how the decline in shared social spaces such as local shops impacts on social relationships. 'Bonding' highlighted how community group membership can have positive and negative implications for individuals and the wider community. It was found that skilled group leadership was key to strengthening bridging capital. Politically, in the UK, community participation is seen as having an essential role in social change, for example, its centrality to the coalition government's idea of the 'Big Society'. A micro-examination of this HLC using the lens of social capital provides a valuable critical insight into community participation. It shows that this kind of initiative can be successful in building social capital, given conditions such as an appropriate setting and effective leadership. However, they cannot substitute for other kinds of investment in the physical infrastructure of a community.",
keywords = "Bonding, Bridging, Community participation, Healthy Living Centre, Putnam, Social capital, Template analysis",
author = "Emma Kirkby-Geddes and Nigel King and Alison Bravington",
year = "2013",
month = "7",
doi = "10.1002/casp.2118",
language = "English",
volume = "23",
pages = "271--285",
journal = "Journal of Community and Applied Social Psychology",
issn = "1052-9284",
publisher = "John Wiley and Sons Ltd",
number = "4",

}

Social Capital and Community Group Participation : Examining 'Bridging' and 'Bonding' in the Context of a Healthy Living Centre in the UK. / Kirkby-Geddes, Emma; King, Nigel; Bravington, Alison.

In: Journal of Community and Applied Social Psychology, Vol. 23, No. 4, 07.2013, p. 271-285.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Social Capital and Community Group Participation

T2 - Examining 'Bridging' and 'Bonding' in the Context of a Healthy Living Centre in the UK

AU - Kirkby-Geddes, Emma

AU - King, Nigel

AU - Bravington, Alison

PY - 2013/7

Y1 - 2013/7

N2 - Social capital has been widely advocated as a way of understanding and building community participation in the interest of health improvement. However, the concept as proposed by Putnam, has been criticised for presenting an overly romanticised account of complex community relations. This paper presents analysis from a qualitative evaluation of a Healthy Living Centre (HLC) in the North of England, to examine the utility of the concept of social capital in this context. We found the concepts of 'bridging' and 'bonding' social capital were useful - though not without limitations - in helping to make sense of the complexities and contradictions in participants' experiences of community group participation. 'Bridging' helped provide an understanding of how the decline in shared social spaces such as local shops impacts on social relationships. 'Bonding' highlighted how community group membership can have positive and negative implications for individuals and the wider community. It was found that skilled group leadership was key to strengthening bridging capital. Politically, in the UK, community participation is seen as having an essential role in social change, for example, its centrality to the coalition government's idea of the 'Big Society'. A micro-examination of this HLC using the lens of social capital provides a valuable critical insight into community participation. It shows that this kind of initiative can be successful in building social capital, given conditions such as an appropriate setting and effective leadership. However, they cannot substitute for other kinds of investment in the physical infrastructure of a community.

AB - Social capital has been widely advocated as a way of understanding and building community participation in the interest of health improvement. However, the concept as proposed by Putnam, has been criticised for presenting an overly romanticised account of complex community relations. This paper presents analysis from a qualitative evaluation of a Healthy Living Centre (HLC) in the North of England, to examine the utility of the concept of social capital in this context. We found the concepts of 'bridging' and 'bonding' social capital were useful - though not without limitations - in helping to make sense of the complexities and contradictions in participants' experiences of community group participation. 'Bridging' helped provide an understanding of how the decline in shared social spaces such as local shops impacts on social relationships. 'Bonding' highlighted how community group membership can have positive and negative implications for individuals and the wider community. It was found that skilled group leadership was key to strengthening bridging capital. Politically, in the UK, community participation is seen as having an essential role in social change, for example, its centrality to the coalition government's idea of the 'Big Society'. A micro-examination of this HLC using the lens of social capital provides a valuable critical insight into community participation. It shows that this kind of initiative can be successful in building social capital, given conditions such as an appropriate setting and effective leadership. However, they cannot substitute for other kinds of investment in the physical infrastructure of a community.

KW - Bonding

KW - Bridging

KW - Community participation

KW - Healthy Living Centre

KW - Putnam

KW - Social capital

KW - Template analysis

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84879505458&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/casp.2118

DO - 10.1002/casp.2118

M3 - Article

VL - 23

SP - 271

EP - 285

JO - Journal of Community and Applied Social Psychology

JF - Journal of Community and Applied Social Psychology

SN - 1052-9284

IS - 4

ER -