The Economics, Culture and Politics of Hospital Contributory Schemes

The Case of Inter-war Leeds

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The funding of hospitals in inter-war Britain was transformed by the development of a range of schemes designed to raise money from patients in return for more or less assured access to treatment. Drawing on the nineteenth-century traditions of mutual benefit societies and thrift agencies as well as the culture of trade unions, co-operative societies, and friendly societies, they brought together small contributions to pool risk and costs for the workers. However, despite important recent research which has gone some way to opening up the operation of these schemes to greater scrutiny and understanding, their social, cultural, and political make-up have received limited attention and we know very little about who joined, how the schemes operated on a day-to-day basis, and the extent to which they became politicized in the increasingly class-ridden inter-war years. This article considers these themes through a case study of the Leeds and District Workpeople's Hospital Fund. Drawing on annual reports, the Leeds Hospital Magazine, and the unpublished records of the scheme, it examines how the Fund was organized on the ground, who ran it, and if it was prone to class, ethnic, and political segregation. Inter alia it explores whether the Fund continued to operate as a pan-class, mutual-benefit, activist organization or if it succumbed to functionalist demands to provide insurance and guaranteed treatment.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)289-315
Number of pages27
JournalLabour History Review
Volume77
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2012

Fingerprint

Economics
Leeds
Insurance
Annual reports
Segregation
Limited attention
Costs
Trade unions
Funding
Co-operative societies
Thrifts
Workers
Functionalist
Scrutiny
Trade Unions
Annual Reports
Interwar Years
Friendly Societies
Activists

Cite this

@article{623356af2a564791a5189e05ffa8608d,
title = "The Economics, Culture and Politics of Hospital Contributory Schemes: The Case of Inter-war Leeds",
abstract = "The funding of hospitals in inter-war Britain was transformed by the development of a range of schemes designed to raise money from patients in return for more or less assured access to treatment. Drawing on the nineteenth-century traditions of mutual benefit societies and thrift agencies as well as the culture of trade unions, co-operative societies, and friendly societies, they brought together small contributions to pool risk and costs for the workers. However, despite important recent research which has gone some way to opening up the operation of these schemes to greater scrutiny and understanding, their social, cultural, and political make-up have received limited attention and we know very little about who joined, how the schemes operated on a day-to-day basis, and the extent to which they became politicized in the increasingly class-ridden inter-war years. This article considers these themes through a case study of the Leeds and District Workpeople's Hospital Fund. Drawing on annual reports, the Leeds Hospital Magazine, and the unpublished records of the scheme, it examines how the Fund was organized on the ground, who ran it, and if it was prone to class, ethnic, and political segregation. Inter alia it explores whether the Fund continued to operate as a pan-class, mutual-benefit, activist organization or if it succumbed to functionalist demands to provide insurance and guaranteed treatment.",
keywords = "Leeds and District Workpeople's Hospital Fund, LWHF, hospital contributory schemes",
author = "Barry Doyle",
year = "2012",
doi = "10.3828/lhr.2012.17",
language = "English",
volume = "77",
pages = "289--315",
journal = "Labour History Review",
issn = "0961-5652",
publisher = "Maney Publishing",
number = "3",

}

The Economics, Culture and Politics of Hospital Contributory Schemes : The Case of Inter-war Leeds. / Doyle, Barry.

In: Labour History Review, Vol. 77, No. 3, 2012, p. 289-315.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - The Economics, Culture and Politics of Hospital Contributory Schemes

T2 - The Case of Inter-war Leeds

AU - Doyle, Barry

PY - 2012

Y1 - 2012

N2 - The funding of hospitals in inter-war Britain was transformed by the development of a range of schemes designed to raise money from patients in return for more or less assured access to treatment. Drawing on the nineteenth-century traditions of mutual benefit societies and thrift agencies as well as the culture of trade unions, co-operative societies, and friendly societies, they brought together small contributions to pool risk and costs for the workers. However, despite important recent research which has gone some way to opening up the operation of these schemes to greater scrutiny and understanding, their social, cultural, and political make-up have received limited attention and we know very little about who joined, how the schemes operated on a day-to-day basis, and the extent to which they became politicized in the increasingly class-ridden inter-war years. This article considers these themes through a case study of the Leeds and District Workpeople's Hospital Fund. Drawing on annual reports, the Leeds Hospital Magazine, and the unpublished records of the scheme, it examines how the Fund was organized on the ground, who ran it, and if it was prone to class, ethnic, and political segregation. Inter alia it explores whether the Fund continued to operate as a pan-class, mutual-benefit, activist organization or if it succumbed to functionalist demands to provide insurance and guaranteed treatment.

AB - The funding of hospitals in inter-war Britain was transformed by the development of a range of schemes designed to raise money from patients in return for more or less assured access to treatment. Drawing on the nineteenth-century traditions of mutual benefit societies and thrift agencies as well as the culture of trade unions, co-operative societies, and friendly societies, they brought together small contributions to pool risk and costs for the workers. However, despite important recent research which has gone some way to opening up the operation of these schemes to greater scrutiny and understanding, their social, cultural, and political make-up have received limited attention and we know very little about who joined, how the schemes operated on a day-to-day basis, and the extent to which they became politicized in the increasingly class-ridden inter-war years. This article considers these themes through a case study of the Leeds and District Workpeople's Hospital Fund. Drawing on annual reports, the Leeds Hospital Magazine, and the unpublished records of the scheme, it examines how the Fund was organized on the ground, who ran it, and if it was prone to class, ethnic, and political segregation. Inter alia it explores whether the Fund continued to operate as a pan-class, mutual-benefit, activist organization or if it succumbed to functionalist demands to provide insurance and guaranteed treatment.

KW - Leeds and District Workpeople's Hospital Fund

KW - LWHF

KW - hospital contributory schemes

U2 - 10.3828/lhr.2012.17

DO - 10.3828/lhr.2012.17

M3 - Article

VL - 77

SP - 289

EP - 315

JO - Labour History Review

JF - Labour History Review

SN - 0961-5652

IS - 3

ER -