The micropolitics of behavioural interventions: a new materialist analysis

Nick J Fox, Elise Klein

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Behavioural approaches are increasingly used in both the global North and South as means to effect government policy. These interventions aim to encourage preferred behaviours by subtly shaping choices, applying incentives or employing punitive measures. Recent digital technology developments extend the reach of these behavioural approaches. While these approaches have
been criticised from political science perspectives, in this paper we apply an innovative mode of analysis of behavioural policy approaches founded in a ‘new materialist’ ontology of affects, assemblages and capacities. This perspective enables us to explore their ‘micropolitical’ impact – on those who are their subjects, but also upon the wider sociocultural contexts within which they
have been implemented. We examine two different behavioural interventions: the use of vouchers to incentivise new mothers to breastfeed their infants (a practice associated with improved health outcomes in both childhood and later life), and uses of debit card technologies in Australia to limit welfare recipients’ spending on alcohol, drugs and gambling. In each case, we employ a materialist methodology to analyse precisely what these interventions do, and what
(in)capacities they produce in their targeted groups. From these we draw out a more generalised critique of behavioural approaches to policy implementation.
LanguageEnglish
JournalBioSocieties
Early online date23 Apr 2019
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 23 Apr 2019

Fingerprint

micro-politics
Gambling
Policy Making
Motivation
welfare recipient
policy approach
Alcohols
policy implementation
Mothers
gambling
Technology
ontology
political science
government policy
infant
Health
childhood
alcohol
incentive
Pharmaceutical Preparations

Cite this

@article{f7a863714b97417faa797e215c1ee7a5,
title = "The micropolitics of behavioural interventions: a new materialist analysis",
abstract = "Behavioural approaches are increasingly used in both the global North and South as means to effect government policy. These interventions aim to encourage preferred behaviours by subtly shaping choices, applying incentives or employing punitive measures. Recent digital technology developments extend the reach of these behavioural approaches. While these approaches havebeen criticised from political science perspectives, in this paper we apply an innovative mode of analysis of behavioural policy approaches founded in a ‘new materialist’ ontology of affects, assemblages and capacities. This perspective enables us to explore their ‘micropolitical’ impact – on those who are their subjects, but also upon the wider sociocultural contexts within which theyhave been implemented. We examine two different behavioural interventions: the use of vouchers to incentivise new mothers to breastfeed their infants (a practice associated with improved health outcomes in both childhood and later life), and uses of debit card technologies in Australia to limit welfare recipients’ spending on alcohol, drugs and gambling. In each case, we employ a materialist methodology to analyse precisely what these interventions do, and what(in)capacities they produce in their targeted groups. From these we draw out a more generalised critique of behavioural approaches to policy implementation.",
keywords = "Affect Assemblage Behavioural economics Micropolitics New materialism ‘nudge’ Policy, Behavioural economics, Policy, ‘nudge’, Assemblage, Affect, Micropolitics, New materialism",
author = "Fox, {Nick J} and Elise Klein",
year = "2019",
month = "4",
day = "23",
doi = "10.1057/s41292-019-00153-9",
language = "English",
journal = "BioSocieties",
issn = "1745-8552",
publisher = "Palgrave Macmillan Ltd.",

}

The micropolitics of behavioural interventions : a new materialist analysis. / Fox, Nick J; Klein, Elise.

In: BioSocieties, 23.04.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - The micropolitics of behavioural interventions

T2 - BioSocieties

AU - Fox, Nick J

AU - Klein, Elise

PY - 2019/4/23

Y1 - 2019/4/23

N2 - Behavioural approaches are increasingly used in both the global North and South as means to effect government policy. These interventions aim to encourage preferred behaviours by subtly shaping choices, applying incentives or employing punitive measures. Recent digital technology developments extend the reach of these behavioural approaches. While these approaches havebeen criticised from political science perspectives, in this paper we apply an innovative mode of analysis of behavioural policy approaches founded in a ‘new materialist’ ontology of affects, assemblages and capacities. This perspective enables us to explore their ‘micropolitical’ impact – on those who are their subjects, but also upon the wider sociocultural contexts within which theyhave been implemented. We examine two different behavioural interventions: the use of vouchers to incentivise new mothers to breastfeed their infants (a practice associated with improved health outcomes in both childhood and later life), and uses of debit card technologies in Australia to limit welfare recipients’ spending on alcohol, drugs and gambling. In each case, we employ a materialist methodology to analyse precisely what these interventions do, and what(in)capacities they produce in their targeted groups. From these we draw out a more generalised critique of behavioural approaches to policy implementation.

AB - Behavioural approaches are increasingly used in both the global North and South as means to effect government policy. These interventions aim to encourage preferred behaviours by subtly shaping choices, applying incentives or employing punitive measures. Recent digital technology developments extend the reach of these behavioural approaches. While these approaches havebeen criticised from political science perspectives, in this paper we apply an innovative mode of analysis of behavioural policy approaches founded in a ‘new materialist’ ontology of affects, assemblages and capacities. This perspective enables us to explore their ‘micropolitical’ impact – on those who are their subjects, but also upon the wider sociocultural contexts within which theyhave been implemented. We examine two different behavioural interventions: the use of vouchers to incentivise new mothers to breastfeed their infants (a practice associated with improved health outcomes in both childhood and later life), and uses of debit card technologies in Australia to limit welfare recipients’ spending on alcohol, drugs and gambling. In each case, we employ a materialist methodology to analyse precisely what these interventions do, and what(in)capacities they produce in their targeted groups. From these we draw out a more generalised critique of behavioural approaches to policy implementation.

KW - Affect Assemblage Behavioural economics Micropolitics New materialism ‘nudge’ Policy

KW - Behavioural economics

KW - Policy

KW - ‘nudge’

KW - Assemblage

KW - Affect

KW - Micropolitics

KW - New materialism

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85064919887&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1057/s41292-019-00153-9

DO - 10.1057/s41292-019-00153-9

M3 - Article

JO - BioSocieties

JF - BioSocieties

SN - 1745-8552

ER -