The Perception of Hyper-Compression by Mastering Engineers

Malachy Ronan, Nicholas Ward, Robert Sazdov, Hyunkook Lee

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Hyper-compressed popular music is the product of a behavior associated with the over-use of dynamic range processing in an effort to gain a competitive advantage in music production. This behavior is unnecessary given the introduction of loudness normalization algorithms across the industry and has been denounced by mastering engineers as generating audible sound quality artifacts. However, the audibility of these sound quality artifacts to mastering engineers has not been examined. This study probes this question using an ABX listening experiment with 20 mastering engineers. On average, mastering engineers correctly discriminated 17 out of 24 conditions suggesting that the sound quality artifacts generated by hyper-compression are difficult to perceive. The findings in the study suggest that audibility depends on the Crest Factor (CF) of the music rather than the amount of CF reduction thus proposing the existence of a threshold of audibility. Further work focusing on education initiatives are offered.

LanguageEnglish
Pages613-621
Number of pages9
JournalAES: Journal of the Audio Engineering Society
Volume65
Issue number7/8
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jul 2017

Fingerprint

Engineers
Acoustic waves
Education
Compression
Processing
Sound
Artifact
Industry
Experiments
Music
Popular music
Competitive Advantage
Normalization
Experiment
Loudness

Cite this

Ronan, Malachy ; Ward, Nicholas ; Sazdov, Robert ; Lee, Hyunkook. / The Perception of Hyper-Compression by Mastering Engineers. In: AES: Journal of the Audio Engineering Society. 2017 ; Vol. 65, No. 7/8. pp. 613-621.
@article{25e6a8f88a204ef99751bb3f8f333ee2,
title = "The Perception of Hyper-Compression by Mastering Engineers",
abstract = "Hyper-compressed popular music is the product of a behavior associated with the over-use of dynamic range processing in an effort to gain a competitive advantage in music production. This behavior is unnecessary given the introduction of loudness normalization algorithms across the industry and has been denounced by mastering engineers as generating audible sound quality artifacts. However, the audibility of these sound quality artifacts to mastering engineers has not been examined. This study probes this question using an ABX listening experiment with 20 mastering engineers. On average, mastering engineers correctly discriminated 17 out of 24 conditions suggesting that the sound quality artifacts generated by hyper-compression are difficult to perceive. The findings in the study suggest that audibility depends on the Crest Factor (CF) of the music rather than the amount of CF reduction thus proposing the existence of a threshold of audibility. Further work focusing on education initiatives are offered.",
author = "Malachy Ronan and Nicholas Ward and Robert Sazdov and Hyunkook Lee",
note = "Publisher actively disallows archiving of AAM (see Sherpa).",
year = "2017",
month = "7",
day = "1",
doi = "10.17743/jaes.2017.0023",
language = "English",
volume = "65",
pages = "613--621",
journal = "AES: Journal of the Audio Engineering Society",
issn = "0004-7554",
publisher = "Audio Engineering Society",
number = "7/8",

}

The Perception of Hyper-Compression by Mastering Engineers. / Ronan, Malachy; Ward, Nicholas; Sazdov, Robert; Lee, Hyunkook.

In: AES: Journal of the Audio Engineering Society, Vol. 65, No. 7/8, 01.07.2017, p. 613-621.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - The Perception of Hyper-Compression by Mastering Engineers

AU - Ronan, Malachy

AU - Ward, Nicholas

AU - Sazdov, Robert

AU - Lee, Hyunkook

N1 - Publisher actively disallows archiving of AAM (see Sherpa).

PY - 2017/7/1

Y1 - 2017/7/1

N2 - Hyper-compressed popular music is the product of a behavior associated with the over-use of dynamic range processing in an effort to gain a competitive advantage in music production. This behavior is unnecessary given the introduction of loudness normalization algorithms across the industry and has been denounced by mastering engineers as generating audible sound quality artifacts. However, the audibility of these sound quality artifacts to mastering engineers has not been examined. This study probes this question using an ABX listening experiment with 20 mastering engineers. On average, mastering engineers correctly discriminated 17 out of 24 conditions suggesting that the sound quality artifacts generated by hyper-compression are difficult to perceive. The findings in the study suggest that audibility depends on the Crest Factor (CF) of the music rather than the amount of CF reduction thus proposing the existence of a threshold of audibility. Further work focusing on education initiatives are offered.

AB - Hyper-compressed popular music is the product of a behavior associated with the over-use of dynamic range processing in an effort to gain a competitive advantage in music production. This behavior is unnecessary given the introduction of loudness normalization algorithms across the industry and has been denounced by mastering engineers as generating audible sound quality artifacts. However, the audibility of these sound quality artifacts to mastering engineers has not been examined. This study probes this question using an ABX listening experiment with 20 mastering engineers. On average, mastering engineers correctly discriminated 17 out of 24 conditions suggesting that the sound quality artifacts generated by hyper-compression are difficult to perceive. The findings in the study suggest that audibility depends on the Crest Factor (CF) of the music rather than the amount of CF reduction thus proposing the existence of a threshold of audibility. Further work focusing on education initiatives are offered.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85028560380&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.aes.org/journal/

U2 - 10.17743/jaes.2017.0023

DO - 10.17743/jaes.2017.0023

M3 - Article

VL - 65

SP - 613

EP - 621

JO - AES: Journal of the Audio Engineering Society

T2 - AES: Journal of the Audio Engineering Society

JF - AES: Journal of the Audio Engineering Society

SN - 0004-7554

IS - 7/8

ER -