The West, the rest, and the 'war on terror': Representation of Muslims in neoconservative media discourse

George Kassimeris, Leonie Jackson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This paper uses Sayyid's concept of Eurocentrism to analyse neoconservative media discourse following the September 11 attacks. Using predicate analysis on articles from The Weekly Standard magazine, this study aims to determine how neoconservative writers created a Muslim subjectivity following the attacks in order to make certain courses of action appear necessary and inevitable. Four subject positions emerged from the analysis: passive Muslims, active Muslims, the passive West, and the active West. By containing and controlling the representation of 'Islam' and 'Muslims' through these binaries, neoconservatives endeavoured to stabilise the identities of the players in the 'war on terrorism', and in doing so, advanced a Eurocentric discourse that attempted to re-centre the West as the vehicle of human progress, with America as its natural leader. This paper concludes that basing the 'war on terror' entirely around identities effectively made Eurocentrism (and Islamism) self-reinforcing, as the successful restriction of identities precluded challenges to the neoconservative discourse from any position other than a 'Muslim' subjectivity.

LanguageEnglish
Pages19-33
Number of pages15
JournalContemporary Politics
Volume17
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Mar 2011
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

terrorism
Muslim
discourse
Eurocentrism
subjectivity
islamism
magazine
Islam
writer
leader

Cite this

@article{830408cbdf1d473ca620e6274e3188cc,
title = "The West, the rest, and the 'war on terror': Representation of Muslims in neoconservative media discourse",
abstract = "This paper uses Sayyid's concept of Eurocentrism to analyse neoconservative media discourse following the September 11 attacks. Using predicate analysis on articles from The Weekly Standard magazine, this study aims to determine how neoconservative writers created a Muslim subjectivity following the attacks in order to make certain courses of action appear necessary and inevitable. Four subject positions emerged from the analysis: passive Muslims, active Muslims, the passive West, and the active West. By containing and controlling the representation of 'Islam' and 'Muslims' through these binaries, neoconservatives endeavoured to stabilise the identities of the players in the 'war on terrorism', and in doing so, advanced a Eurocentric discourse that attempted to re-centre the West as the vehicle of human progress, with America as its natural leader. This paper concludes that basing the 'war on terror' entirely around identities effectively made Eurocentrism (and Islamism) self-reinforcing, as the successful restriction of identities precluded challenges to the neoconservative discourse from any position other than a 'Muslim' subjectivity.",
keywords = "Eurocentrism, Islam, Media discourse, Neoconservatism, War on terror",
author = "George Kassimeris and Leonie Jackson",
year = "2011",
month = "3",
doi = "10.1080/13569775.2011.552684",
language = "English",
volume = "17",
pages = "19--33",
journal = "Contemporary Politics",
issn = "1356-9775",
publisher = "Routledge",
number = "1",

}

The West, the rest, and the 'war on terror' : Representation of Muslims in neoconservative media discourse. / Kassimeris, George; Jackson, Leonie.

In: Contemporary Politics, Vol. 17, No. 1, 03.2011, p. 19-33.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - The West, the rest, and the 'war on terror'

T2 - Contemporary Politics

AU - Kassimeris, George

AU - Jackson, Leonie

PY - 2011/3

Y1 - 2011/3

N2 - This paper uses Sayyid's concept of Eurocentrism to analyse neoconservative media discourse following the September 11 attacks. Using predicate analysis on articles from The Weekly Standard magazine, this study aims to determine how neoconservative writers created a Muslim subjectivity following the attacks in order to make certain courses of action appear necessary and inevitable. Four subject positions emerged from the analysis: passive Muslims, active Muslims, the passive West, and the active West. By containing and controlling the representation of 'Islam' and 'Muslims' through these binaries, neoconservatives endeavoured to stabilise the identities of the players in the 'war on terrorism', and in doing so, advanced a Eurocentric discourse that attempted to re-centre the West as the vehicle of human progress, with America as its natural leader. This paper concludes that basing the 'war on terror' entirely around identities effectively made Eurocentrism (and Islamism) self-reinforcing, as the successful restriction of identities precluded challenges to the neoconservative discourse from any position other than a 'Muslim' subjectivity.

AB - This paper uses Sayyid's concept of Eurocentrism to analyse neoconservative media discourse following the September 11 attacks. Using predicate analysis on articles from The Weekly Standard magazine, this study aims to determine how neoconservative writers created a Muslim subjectivity following the attacks in order to make certain courses of action appear necessary and inevitable. Four subject positions emerged from the analysis: passive Muslims, active Muslims, the passive West, and the active West. By containing and controlling the representation of 'Islam' and 'Muslims' through these binaries, neoconservatives endeavoured to stabilise the identities of the players in the 'war on terrorism', and in doing so, advanced a Eurocentric discourse that attempted to re-centre the West as the vehicle of human progress, with America as its natural leader. This paper concludes that basing the 'war on terror' entirely around identities effectively made Eurocentrism (and Islamism) self-reinforcing, as the successful restriction of identities precluded challenges to the neoconservative discourse from any position other than a 'Muslim' subjectivity.

KW - Eurocentrism

KW - Islam

KW - Media discourse

KW - Neoconservatism

KW - War on terror

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=79952671826&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.tandfonline.com/toc/ccpo20/current

U2 - 10.1080/13569775.2011.552684

DO - 10.1080/13569775.2011.552684

M3 - Article

VL - 17

SP - 19

EP - 33

JO - Contemporary Politics

JF - Contemporary Politics

SN - 1356-9775

IS - 1

ER -