Vital Parameters for Patent Morality: A question of form

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Legal context
At the interface between patent law and biotechnology, a debate has arisen over the application of the morality provision, designed to ensure the future development of society on a principled basis. This article reviews the provision in its European context, adopting UK and European perspectives for analysis.

Key points
Analysis of the provision identifies that there is ambiguity regarding interpretation of the morality provision, which has lead to inconsistent application between the European Patent Office and the European Patent Boards. This article assesses the provision in the context of the patent system and offers a legal philosophy framework within which to understand the provision as conveying: a methodology, a standard of morality and a source for that standard which can be utilized to describe the possibilities. It then re-centres the debate to its practical context in order to demonstrate that the patent system removes the options which are inapplicable: advocating valid and achievable methods for complying with the law both nationally and on a European level.

Practical significance
The morality provision has become an accepted ‘wild card’ in assessing the patentability of biotechnology: it has come to rely upon the identification of danger areas in innovation that may trigger moral objections. This falls far short of the legal certainty which is so vital to biotechnological growth. In the face of the impending implementation of the unitary patent right across Europe, the importance of achieving a predictable and practical approach to applying the morality cannot be underestimated.
LanguageEnglish
Pages832-846
Number of pages15
JournalJournal of Intellectual Property Law & Practice
Volume2
Issue number12
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Dec 2007
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

patent
morality
patent system
biotechnology
patent law
social development
innovation
interpretation
Law
methodology

Cite this

@article{6234000249904885800d1d67c47d3712,
title = "Vital Parameters for Patent Morality: A question of form",
abstract = "Legal contextAt the interface between patent law and biotechnology, a debate has arisen over the application of the morality provision, designed to ensure the future development of society on a principled basis. This article reviews the provision in its European context, adopting UK and European perspectives for analysis.Key pointsAnalysis of the provision identifies that there is ambiguity regarding interpretation of the morality provision, which has lead to inconsistent application between the European Patent Office and the European Patent Boards. This article assesses the provision in the context of the patent system and offers a legal philosophy framework within which to understand the provision as conveying: a methodology, a standard of morality and a source for that standard which can be utilized to describe the possibilities. It then re-centres the debate to its practical context in order to demonstrate that the patent system removes the options which are inapplicable: advocating valid and achievable methods for complying with the law both nationally and on a European level.Practical significanceThe morality provision has become an accepted ‘wild card’ in assessing the patentability of biotechnology: it has come to rely upon the identification of danger areas in innovation that may trigger moral objections. This falls far short of the legal certainty which is so vital to biotechnological growth. In the face of the impending implementation of the unitary patent right across Europe, the importance of achieving a predictable and practical approach to applying the morality cannot be underestimated.",
author = "Amanda Warren-Jones",
year = "2007",
month = "12",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1093/jiplp/jpm190",
language = "English",
volume = "2",
pages = "832--846",
journal = "Journal of Intellectual Property Law & Practice",
issn = "1747-1540",
publisher = "Oxford University Press",
number = "12",

}

Vital Parameters for Patent Morality : A question of form. / Warren-Jones, Amanda.

In: Journal of Intellectual Property Law & Practice, Vol. 2, No. 12, 01.12.2007, p. 832-846.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Vital Parameters for Patent Morality

T2 - Journal of Intellectual Property Law & Practice

AU - Warren-Jones, Amanda

PY - 2007/12/1

Y1 - 2007/12/1

N2 - Legal contextAt the interface between patent law and biotechnology, a debate has arisen over the application of the morality provision, designed to ensure the future development of society on a principled basis. This article reviews the provision in its European context, adopting UK and European perspectives for analysis.Key pointsAnalysis of the provision identifies that there is ambiguity regarding interpretation of the morality provision, which has lead to inconsistent application between the European Patent Office and the European Patent Boards. This article assesses the provision in the context of the patent system and offers a legal philosophy framework within which to understand the provision as conveying: a methodology, a standard of morality and a source for that standard which can be utilized to describe the possibilities. It then re-centres the debate to its practical context in order to demonstrate that the patent system removes the options which are inapplicable: advocating valid and achievable methods for complying with the law both nationally and on a European level.Practical significanceThe morality provision has become an accepted ‘wild card’ in assessing the patentability of biotechnology: it has come to rely upon the identification of danger areas in innovation that may trigger moral objections. This falls far short of the legal certainty which is so vital to biotechnological growth. In the face of the impending implementation of the unitary patent right across Europe, the importance of achieving a predictable and practical approach to applying the morality cannot be underestimated.

AB - Legal contextAt the interface between patent law and biotechnology, a debate has arisen over the application of the morality provision, designed to ensure the future development of society on a principled basis. This article reviews the provision in its European context, adopting UK and European perspectives for analysis.Key pointsAnalysis of the provision identifies that there is ambiguity regarding interpretation of the morality provision, which has lead to inconsistent application between the European Patent Office and the European Patent Boards. This article assesses the provision in the context of the patent system and offers a legal philosophy framework within which to understand the provision as conveying: a methodology, a standard of morality and a source for that standard which can be utilized to describe the possibilities. It then re-centres the debate to its practical context in order to demonstrate that the patent system removes the options which are inapplicable: advocating valid and achievable methods for complying with the law both nationally and on a European level.Practical significanceThe morality provision has become an accepted ‘wild card’ in assessing the patentability of biotechnology: it has come to rely upon the identification of danger areas in innovation that may trigger moral objections. This falls far short of the legal certainty which is so vital to biotechnological growth. In the face of the impending implementation of the unitary patent right across Europe, the importance of achieving a predictable and practical approach to applying the morality cannot be underestimated.

U2 - 10.1093/jiplp/jpm190

DO - 10.1093/jiplp/jpm190

M3 - Article

VL - 2

SP - 832

EP - 846

JO - Journal of Intellectual Property Law & Practice

JF - Journal of Intellectual Property Law & Practice

SN - 1747-1540

IS - 12

ER -