Volumetric wear assessment of retrieved metal-on-metal hip prostheses and the impact of measurement uncertainty

P.J. Bills, R. Racasan, R.J. Underwood, P. Cann, J. Skinner, A.J. Hart, X. Jiang, L. Blunt

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

47 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In hip replacement the use of hard bearing materials, which have been shown to have lower wear rates than traditional metal-UHMWPE couples, has been encouraged in an effort to extend component life-in-service. With a view to further extending this period of joint activity metal-on-metal hip resurfacings have been developed which allow for implantation into younger and more active patients. However, these bearings have recently been the subject of a MHRA device alert due to unexplained hip pain and reported soft tissue reactions and indeed are under investigation having been shown to exhibit high failure rates. This has highlighted the need for a traceable metrological approach to the quantification and characterization of in vivo wear as currently there is no standard dedicated to the measurement of such wear. This study is the first to develop a comprehensive method for measuring the wear geometry of retrieved bearings whilst also assessing and quantifying both the magnitude and effect of the three-dimensional measurement uncertainty on the measurement process as a whole. This study shows that the magnitude of the expanded measurement uncertainty is an important, and until now overlooked, factor and that a statement of uncertainty is vital in measuring retrieved components as a means of comparison between studies and as a measure of confidence in measurement data. Based on the results of this study, it is recommended that care be taken when performing wear measurements on retrieved bearings. Factors such as point pitch and scan line separation can have a great effect on the likely uncertainty of the obtained measurement result and indeed the uncertainty of the measurement can be of the same order as the wear being measured.
LanguageEnglish
Pages212-219
Number of pages8
JournalWear
Volume274-275
Early online date12 Sep 2011
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jan 2012

Fingerprint

Hip prostheses
Bearings (structural)
Metals
Wear of materials
metals
Ultrahigh molecular weight polyethylenes
Uncertainty
dimensional measurement
pain
Service life
confidence
implantation
Tissue
Geometry

Cite this

@article{c7ea285a24ee434abd7dadad6d4bd188,
title = "Volumetric wear assessment of retrieved metal-on-metal hip prostheses and the impact of measurement uncertainty",
abstract = "In hip replacement the use of hard bearing materials, which have been shown to have lower wear rates than traditional metal-UHMWPE couples, has been encouraged in an effort to extend component life-in-service. With a view to further extending this period of joint activity metal-on-metal hip resurfacings have been developed which allow for implantation into younger and more active patients. However, these bearings have recently been the subject of a MHRA device alert due to unexplained hip pain and reported soft tissue reactions and indeed are under investigation having been shown to exhibit high failure rates. This has highlighted the need for a traceable metrological approach to the quantification and characterization of in vivo wear as currently there is no standard dedicated to the measurement of such wear. This study is the first to develop a comprehensive method for measuring the wear geometry of retrieved bearings whilst also assessing and quantifying both the magnitude and effect of the three-dimensional measurement uncertainty on the measurement process as a whole. This study shows that the magnitude of the expanded measurement uncertainty is an important, and until now overlooked, factor and that a statement of uncertainty is vital in measuring retrieved components as a means of comparison between studies and as a measure of confidence in measurement data. Based on the results of this study, it is recommended that care be taken when performing wear measurements on retrieved bearings. Factors such as point pitch and scan line separation can have a great effect on the likely uncertainty of the obtained measurement result and indeed the uncertainty of the measurement can be of the same order as the wear being measured.",
keywords = "Wear measurement, Retrieved bearings, Hip replacement, CMM, Measurement uncertainty",
author = "P.J. Bills and R. Racasan and R.J. Underwood and P. Cann and J. Skinner and A.J. Hart and X. Jiang and L. Blunt",
year = "2012",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.wear.2011.08.030",
language = "English",
volume = "274-275",
pages = "212--219",
journal = "Wear",
issn = "0043-1648",
publisher = "Elsevier BV",

}

Volumetric wear assessment of retrieved metal-on-metal hip prostheses and the impact of measurement uncertainty. / Bills, P.J.; Racasan, R.; Underwood, R.J.; Cann, P.; Skinner, J.; Hart, A.J.; Jiang, X.; Blunt, L.

In: Wear, Vol. 274-275, 01.01.2012, p. 212-219.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Volumetric wear assessment of retrieved metal-on-metal hip prostheses and the impact of measurement uncertainty

AU - Bills, P.J.

AU - Racasan, R.

AU - Underwood, R.J.

AU - Cann, P.

AU - Skinner, J.

AU - Hart, A.J.

AU - Jiang, X.

AU - Blunt, L.

PY - 2012/1/1

Y1 - 2012/1/1

N2 - In hip replacement the use of hard bearing materials, which have been shown to have lower wear rates than traditional metal-UHMWPE couples, has been encouraged in an effort to extend component life-in-service. With a view to further extending this period of joint activity metal-on-metal hip resurfacings have been developed which allow for implantation into younger and more active patients. However, these bearings have recently been the subject of a MHRA device alert due to unexplained hip pain and reported soft tissue reactions and indeed are under investigation having been shown to exhibit high failure rates. This has highlighted the need for a traceable metrological approach to the quantification and characterization of in vivo wear as currently there is no standard dedicated to the measurement of such wear. This study is the first to develop a comprehensive method for measuring the wear geometry of retrieved bearings whilst also assessing and quantifying both the magnitude and effect of the three-dimensional measurement uncertainty on the measurement process as a whole. This study shows that the magnitude of the expanded measurement uncertainty is an important, and until now overlooked, factor and that a statement of uncertainty is vital in measuring retrieved components as a means of comparison between studies and as a measure of confidence in measurement data. Based on the results of this study, it is recommended that care be taken when performing wear measurements on retrieved bearings. Factors such as point pitch and scan line separation can have a great effect on the likely uncertainty of the obtained measurement result and indeed the uncertainty of the measurement can be of the same order as the wear being measured.

AB - In hip replacement the use of hard bearing materials, which have been shown to have lower wear rates than traditional metal-UHMWPE couples, has been encouraged in an effort to extend component life-in-service. With a view to further extending this period of joint activity metal-on-metal hip resurfacings have been developed which allow for implantation into younger and more active patients. However, these bearings have recently been the subject of a MHRA device alert due to unexplained hip pain and reported soft tissue reactions and indeed are under investigation having been shown to exhibit high failure rates. This has highlighted the need for a traceable metrological approach to the quantification and characterization of in vivo wear as currently there is no standard dedicated to the measurement of such wear. This study is the first to develop a comprehensive method for measuring the wear geometry of retrieved bearings whilst also assessing and quantifying both the magnitude and effect of the three-dimensional measurement uncertainty on the measurement process as a whole. This study shows that the magnitude of the expanded measurement uncertainty is an important, and until now overlooked, factor and that a statement of uncertainty is vital in measuring retrieved components as a means of comparison between studies and as a measure of confidence in measurement data. Based on the results of this study, it is recommended that care be taken when performing wear measurements on retrieved bearings. Factors such as point pitch and scan line separation can have a great effect on the likely uncertainty of the obtained measurement result and indeed the uncertainty of the measurement can be of the same order as the wear being measured.

KW - Wear measurement, Retrieved bearings, Hip replacement, CMM, Measurement uncertainty

U2 - 10.1016/j.wear.2011.08.030

DO - 10.1016/j.wear.2011.08.030

M3 - Article

VL - 274-275

SP - 212

EP - 219

JO - Wear

T2 - Wear

JF - Wear

SN - 0043-1648

ER -