Whiplash: The possible impact of context on diagnosis

A E Clough, Jonathan Flynn, J K Home, F Earle, P J Clough

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This study explores the importance of context when diagnosing Whiplash Associated Disorders (WAD). Whiplash is a complex injury and there is considerable variation in its diagnosis and treatment. Research has focussed on RTAs, whilst there is a paucity of evidence relating to WAD in sport. It is unclear whether WAD is simply not occurring in sport, or if such injuries are occurring but are not identified as WAD. In the current study, 87 postgraduate physiotherapists were asked to classify an injury reported in a short vignette. Two parallel vignettes were used, which were identical except for the context of the injury (one being an RTA and the other being within sport). Each participant responded to only one of these. It was found that, even within a sample of experienced physiotherapists, the injury environment impacted on diagnosis, despite the symptoms being identical. A significantly higher proportion of therapists diagnosed WAD within the RTA context than within the sporting context. Additionally, there were differences between the two context groups in relation to the diagnostic terminology used by participants. Most respondents had heard of the CSP whiplash guidelines but only a minority had actively used these. The majority of respondents were also aware of the litigation aspects of RTAs.
LanguageEnglish
Pages4-9
Number of pages6
Journal Pain and Rehabilitation - the Journal of Physiotherapy Pain Association
Volume2015
Issue number38
Publication statusPublished - 2015

Fingerprint

Wounds and Injuries
Sports
Physical Therapists
Jurisprudence
Terminology
Guidelines
Research
Surveys and Questionnaires
Therapeutics

Cite this

@article{3913ec265aad41dc9e823f6513425dbb,
title = "Whiplash: The possible impact of context on diagnosis",
abstract = "This study explores the importance of context when diagnosing Whiplash Associated Disorders (WAD). Whiplash is a complex injury and there is considerable variation in its diagnosis and treatment. Research has focussed on RTAs, whilst there is a paucity of evidence relating to WAD in sport. It is unclear whether WAD is simply not occurring in sport, or if such injuries are occurring but are not identified as WAD. In the current study, 87 postgraduate physiotherapists were asked to classify an injury reported in a short vignette. Two parallel vignettes were used, which were identical except for the context of the injury (one being an RTA and the other being within sport). Each participant responded to only one of these. It was found that, even within a sample of experienced physiotherapists, the injury environment impacted on diagnosis, despite the symptoms being identical. A significantly higher proportion of therapists diagnosed WAD within the RTA context than within the sporting context. Additionally, there were differences between the two context groups in relation to the diagnostic terminology used by participants. Most respondents had heard of the CSP whiplash guidelines but only a minority had actively used these. The majority of respondents were also aware of the litigation aspects of RTAs.",
keywords = "ROAD TRAFFIC ACCIDENT (RTA), WHIPLASH, SPORT",
author = "Clough, {A E} and Jonathan Flynn and Home, {J K} and F Earle and Clough, {P J}",
year = "2015",
language = "English",
volume = "2015",
pages = "4--9",
journal = "Pain and Rehabilitation - the Journal of Physiotherapy Pain Association",
number = "38",

}

Whiplash : The possible impact of context on diagnosis. / Clough, A E; Flynn, Jonathan; Home, J K; Earle, F; Clough, P J .

In: Pain and Rehabilitation - the Journal of Physiotherapy Pain Association, Vol. 2015, No. 38, 2015, p. 4-9.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Whiplash

T2 - Pain and Rehabilitation - the Journal of Physiotherapy Pain Association

AU - Clough, A E

AU - Flynn, Jonathan

AU - Home, J K

AU - Earle, F

AU - Clough, P J

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - This study explores the importance of context when diagnosing Whiplash Associated Disorders (WAD). Whiplash is a complex injury and there is considerable variation in its diagnosis and treatment. Research has focussed on RTAs, whilst there is a paucity of evidence relating to WAD in sport. It is unclear whether WAD is simply not occurring in sport, or if such injuries are occurring but are not identified as WAD. In the current study, 87 postgraduate physiotherapists were asked to classify an injury reported in a short vignette. Two parallel vignettes were used, which were identical except for the context of the injury (one being an RTA and the other being within sport). Each participant responded to only one of these. It was found that, even within a sample of experienced physiotherapists, the injury environment impacted on diagnosis, despite the symptoms being identical. A significantly higher proportion of therapists diagnosed WAD within the RTA context than within the sporting context. Additionally, there were differences between the two context groups in relation to the diagnostic terminology used by participants. Most respondents had heard of the CSP whiplash guidelines but only a minority had actively used these. The majority of respondents were also aware of the litigation aspects of RTAs.

AB - This study explores the importance of context when diagnosing Whiplash Associated Disorders (WAD). Whiplash is a complex injury and there is considerable variation in its diagnosis and treatment. Research has focussed on RTAs, whilst there is a paucity of evidence relating to WAD in sport. It is unclear whether WAD is simply not occurring in sport, or if such injuries are occurring but are not identified as WAD. In the current study, 87 postgraduate physiotherapists were asked to classify an injury reported in a short vignette. Two parallel vignettes were used, which were identical except for the context of the injury (one being an RTA and the other being within sport). Each participant responded to only one of these. It was found that, even within a sample of experienced physiotherapists, the injury environment impacted on diagnosis, despite the symptoms being identical. A significantly higher proportion of therapists diagnosed WAD within the RTA context than within the sporting context. Additionally, there were differences between the two context groups in relation to the diagnostic terminology used by participants. Most respondents had heard of the CSP whiplash guidelines but only a minority had actively used these. The majority of respondents were also aware of the litigation aspects of RTAs.

KW - ROAD TRAFFIC ACCIDENT (RTA)

KW - WHIPLASH

KW - SPORT

M3 - Article

VL - 2015

SP - 4

EP - 9

JO - Pain and Rehabilitation - the Journal of Physiotherapy Pain Association

JF - Pain and Rehabilitation - the Journal of Physiotherapy Pain Association

IS - 38

ER -