A Study of Rural Micro-enterprises
: Increasing Understanding through a Dynamic Capability Lens

  • Karen Wilson

Student thesis: Doctoral Thesis

Abstract

This research investigates rural micro-enterprises, analysing them through the lens of dynamic capability. Rural micro-enterprises are a vibrant, heterogeneous sector within the UK economy (Faherty & Stephens, 2016). Increasing understanding about how rural micro-enterprises develop dynamic capabilities and evolve could contribute towards improving the sustainability of rural communities, encouraging a diverse business base and ultimately helping rural communities survive (Paddock & Marsden, 2015). This research contends that a deeper understanding about how change is manifested within rural micro-enterprises and whether dynamic capabilities (Eisenhardt & Martin, 2000; Teece, 2007; Teece, Pisano & Shuen, 1997) are present within rural micro-enterprises is beneficial to increase understanding of how such business evolve (Kelliher & Reinl, 2009). Increasing such knowledge will help extend develop dynamic capability theory into the rural micro-enterprise domain.

A review of extant literature highlights a knowledge gap concerning dynamic capabilities, rural enterprise and micro-enterprise, with dynamic capability research rarely venturing into the realm of micro-enterprises (Kevill, Trehan, Easterby-Smith, & Higgins, 2015) and seldom into the rural micro-enterprise arena. Context is an important consideration for this research because the majority of dynamic capability research has been conducted within large organisations (Adner & Helfat, 2003), such organisations being intrinsically different from micro-enterprises in their operations. It is anticipated that this empirical research’s findings will contribute to the development of a framework to understand how rural micro-enterprises develop dynamic capabilities and which micro-foundations underpin the identified dynamic capabilities.

This research adopts a qualitative approach. Nineteen narrative interviews were conducted with rural micro-enterprise owner-managers during 2018 across three geographies. This data was supplemented by photographs and an interview with a council policy maker responsible for rural development.

The findings of this research indeed suggest that dynamic capability theory exhibits different attributes in rural micro-enterprises, with a blurring of the lines demarcating Individual-level and organisational-level dynamic capabilities. In addition, due to the influence of the owner-manager, the construct ‘owner-manager faculty’ plays an important role as a micro-foundation of dynamic managerial capability. In some rural micro-enterprises these dynamic managerial capabilities directly influence the business to achieve performance advantage rather than solely acting as a micro-foundation of organisational-level dynamic capabilities. From a rural perspective the findings of this research question extant literature pertaining to rural space/place and the notion that rural microenterprises add value to the rural economy. This research finds in some cases rural micro-enterprises may be negative contributors to rural economic sustainability due to the actions and choices made by the owner-managers. Such owner-managers are classified a ‘parasitical’ in a fresh taxonomy framed by their dynamic capability orientation and rural embeddedness.

It is anticipated that this increased understanding about dynamic capabilities within rural micro-enterprises will help inform policy makers what specific support is needed to enable rural micro-enterprises to establish themselves, grow and thrive within the rural economy to the benefit of rural communities. From a practice perspective, by starting to explore the gap in understanding about dynamic capabilities within rural micro-enterprises insight has been generated which can help rural micro-enterprise owner-managers to better understand how to manage change within their business and compete more effectively within the UK and global marketplace.
Date of Award15 May 2020
Original languageEnglish
SupervisorShelley Harrington (Main Supervisor) & Gerard McElwee (Co-Supervisor)

Cite this

'